Showing posts with label anti-Americanism. Show all posts
Showing posts with label anti-Americanism. Show all posts

Monday, June 07, 2010

How to Stand Up to Israel-Bashers

Jennifer Rubin at "Contentions" offers these tips:How to Stand Up to Israel-Bashers

First, don’t let them define the terms of the debate:
....
Second, debunk ridiculous arguments. Zakaria asks why Bibi isn’t agreeing to an international investigation. Abrams responds:
....
Third, counteract vile accusations with facts:
....
And finally, go on the offense. Zakaria coos over Beinart’s column which asserted that liberals can’t back Israel because of Israel’s conduct. Abrams is having none of it, and turns the tables on Beinart (and, by extension, against the growing cohorts of weaselly critics who now vent Israel-hatred while asserting their Jewish bona fides):....

Hinkle: Israel Committed the One Unforgivable Offense | Richmond Times-Dispatch

A. Barton Hinkle comments on the double standard in effect with Israel: Israel Committed the One Unforgivable Offense | Richmond Times-Dispatch

What's the real problem with Israel's assault on the Gaza flotilla? It's not the loss of life. Almost nobody cares about that. It's not the suffering of Palestinians. When Palestinians suffer, the world shrugs.
....
So what's the real problem with Israel's assault on the flotilla? Not the loss of life. Not the suffering of Palestinians. The real problem is that Jews defended themselves. That is the one offense in the Middle East the world simply will not forgive.

Friday, May 07, 2010

The Soft Bigotry of Insulting Chicanos' Intelligence

The Soft Bigotry of Insulting Chicanos' Intelligence

Yesterday was May 5th, which in Spanish is Cinco de Mayo... which Mexicans do not celebrate as their Independence Day (that would be September 16th, 1810), but which Mexican Americans (Chicanos) celebrate all across the American Southwest and probably elsewhere as well.

On May 5th, 1862, the nationalist militia of Mexico, under the command of Gen. Ignacio Zaragoza, defeated the imperial French forces at the Battala de Puebla. While this didn't end the war with France -- the French fought on for another five years, abandoning their Mexican "colony" only after the United States joined the war on Mexico's side -- Cinco de Mayo is a major Chicano holiday, celebrated primarily by gorging on Mexican food, swigging tequilla, and shooting pistols into the air (kind of like an NBA Finals victory celebration). One hopes the rituals are different in high school.

Yesterday at Live Oak High School in Morgan Hill, in the Santa Clara Valley of California ("Silicon Valley"), school officials celebrated Cinco de Mayo by sending five students home... for wearing American-flag t-shirts.

Principal Nick Boden called the t-shirts "incendiary," according to one of the students. His rationale for threatening the flag-wearers with suspension and then sending them home was that wearing red, white, and blue on Cinco de Mayo was somehow insulting and disrespectful to Hispanic students, which constitute a very large portion of the school's population; however, the school district is unhappy with Boden's action:

Officials at the school chose not to comment on the situation Wednesday, but one student said an official called the T-shirts "incendiary."

"They said we were starting a fight, we were fuel to the fire," said sophomore Matt Dariano.

The Morgan Hill Unified School District issued this statement: "In an attempt to foster a spirit of cultural awareness and maintain a safe and supportive school environment, the Live Oak High School administration took certain actions earlier today.

"The district does not concur with the Live Oak High School administration's interpretation of either board or district policy related to these actions."

I get the sense that the problem has far more to do with the adults involved, from Assistant Principal Miguel Rodriguez (who first ordered the students to remove the flag t-shirts) to Principal Boden to some of the parents of the Chicano students:

A parent of two Live Oak students, Teresa Casillas, said the American-flag wearing students were yelling "We live in America!" at the brunch break. She said her children were upset by their behavior at school, calling it disrespectful.

"We're all offended by it," Casillas said. She said parents of all ethnicities she spoke with felt that way. "Morgan Hill is too small of a community to start any racial wars. This is just bringing it out a little bit more."

Does anybody really believe that "parents of all ethnicities" were offended by five students wearing red, white, and blue, rather than red, white, and green? And does anybody really think the students yelled "we live in America" out of the blue? I think it far more likely they yelled it (if at all) in response to anti-American verbal attacks on them by Hispanic students for daring to wear the colors of their own -- and the Hispanic students' own -- country.

The saddest part is that the vice principal and principal don't even realize how it was they, not the five flag-wearers, who insulted and degraded the Mexican-American students yesterday. What could have been a teaching moment was instead warped by rampant political correctness into an incitement to racism and bigotry... against white students.

Let's suppose some Chicano students complained that the five were wearing American flags on "the only day [Mexican Americans] celebrate their heritage."

  • Think what a revelation it would have been had Miguel Rodriguez explained to them that, while their heritage may be Mexican, they themselves are American citizens... so the American flag is not insulting or disrespectful to them. (I doubt a single one of the protesting students is actually a Mexican citizen.)
  • Imagine if Rodriguez had told them that celebrating a victory by Mexico over France does not require them to attack the United States... which allied with Mexico in that very war.
  • Imagine if he had lectured them about showing civility themselves: The five students didn't tell anyone else not to wear the colors of the Mexican flag; why should Hispanic students demand that their classmates not wear the colors of the American flag -- which is, of course, also the flag of the Hispanic students?

But he didn't.

Instead, the Hispanic assistant principal told all the Hispanic students at Live Oak High School that the American flag is insulting, offensive, and disrespectful... and that they have every right to demand it be excluded from an American school.

Good heavens, could a more bigotted, racist message have been sent if they had deliberately aimed for it? Ergo today, surprise, surprise, 200 Hispanic students marched through Morgan Hills chanting "We want respect!" and "Si se puede!" Oh yes, marching and chanting will get them loads of respect; how could we fail to respect children cutting class to demand we cater to their prejudices?

But it's the subtext that really damages the Hispanic students: Beneath the outspoken charge of "disrespect" is the whispered insinuation that Hispanics are too emotionally fragile to understand that ethnicity is not the same as nationality, and neither is equivalent to identity; the implication that they are Mexicans, not real Americans; and the disconcerting suggestion that other people don't enjoy the same First-Amendment right to freedom of speech as Hispanics themselves.

In other words, it's what George W. Bush called "the soft bigotry of low expectations" all over again. Telling Hispanics they can suppress contrary opinion because it hurts too much is just as bad as telling blacks they should get extra "Negro-points" on their university applications because they're not smart enough to compete fairly with whites, Orientals, and Jews. It's an insidious form of "affirmative action": Whites must tolerate contrary speech -- but not Hispanics, because they can't handle it. What a vile, oppressive, and lying meme to inject into the brain of an adolescent.

Hispanics do not need to be coccooned from the marketplace of ideas. They don't need to be coddled, cradled, sequestered, or sealed in an ideological bubble. There is no reason Americans of Mexican and Central or South American heritage should be less able to handle alternate "truths" than any other ethnic or racial group. If everyone is held to the same standards, kids will understand:

Over at Gilroy High School, Mexican and American patriotic colors commingled peacefully Wednesday, Principal Marco Sanchez said.

"Kids were in good spirits," he said. "I was out on campus most of the day and didn't see anything that was abnormal."

He reported no disciplinary issues as a result of Mexican or American patriotism. Plenty of students donned both both countries' national colors but none were [sic] sent home for wearing green, red, white, blue or any combination thereof, he said. Doing so would be "outrageous," he said.

"We're not going to be sending kids home for wearing American flags or wearing patriotic colors," Sanchez said. "That's discriminatory."

Muchas gracias, Principal Sanchez, for the breath of fresh sanity.

Sunday, August 16, 2009

Geneva Conventions and Hype

The Geneva Conventions were written in an attempt to make war more humane. Merv Benson at Prairie Pundit takes exception to one area where hype seems to rule.

There are several problems that still exist that the media and the ICRC ignore. One of the more obvious problems is treating the Conventions like a unilateral contract binding on signatories regardless of whether adversaries are signatories or abide by the conventions. This gives an unfair advantage to groups like al Qaeda and the Taliban. Thus a televised beheading of non combatants or even POWs are rarely if ever condemned by the ICRC. Yet these same people insist on POW status for unlawful enemy combatants who violate the Conventions. This undermines the conventions and shows a lack of integrity on the part of the ICRC. Has the group ever criticized the Taliban or al Qaeda for unlawfully camouflaging themselves as civilians, putting all civilians at risk? How often do they criticize the Taliban for using human shields? How ofter do they criticize al Qaeda and the Taliban for deliberately targeting non combatants?

If they want to claim relevance they should at least be critical of these aspects of our enemy's operation on a regular basis. Their failure to do so demonstrates a failure of their mission.

Indeed, I've read screeds that hammer the U.S. (and Israel) for any violation of the Conventions, no matter how slight, and no matter how flimsy the evidence. The authors of such screeds are silent on major violations in the other direction. Either they don't grant the other side the status of beings capable of abiding by civilized standards, or they only have vitriol for one party.

Friday, July 10, 2009

Maybe we do need a new word

Over at Commentary's blog, we see:

As far as I know, there is no word in English for the opposite of jingoist. But if there were, its entry in the dictionary would belong next to Barack Obama’s photograph. It seems he can’t set foot on foreign soil without apologizing for this country’s past sins and promising that it will sin no more under his leadership. In doing so, of course, he both disses his own country and praises himself by implication.

Indeed, Gilbert and Sullivan, character never proposed a word for:

The idiot who praises with enthusiastic tone
Each century but this and every country but his own

Because all examples of such would wind up on his little list, and dispatched.

But since we don't have that option, may I propose, "ognijist", from "jingo", spelled backwards?

Monday, December 29, 2008

LA Times' Honest Liberal strikes again

The only shocking thing about this column is that a liberal was actually willing to say this out loud:

I don't love America. That's what conservatives are always telling liberals like me. Their love, they insist, is truer, deeper and more complete. Then liberals, like all people who are accused of not loving something, stammer, get defensive and try to have sex with America even though America will then accuse us of wanting it for its body and not its soul. When America gets like that, there's no winning.

But I've come to believe conservatives are right. They do love America more. Sure, we liberals claim that our love is deeper because we seek to improve the United States by pointing out its flaws. But calling your wife fat isn't love. True love is the blind belief that your child is the smartest, cutest, most charming person in the world, one you would gladly die for. I'm more in "like" with my country.

....

What really struck me most isn't the admission that liberals don't really love the United States the way we conservatives do -- that we already knew, after all -- but the willingness to say so openly in the Los Angeles Times. (Of course, this is the columnist who wrote that he doesn't support the troops.) Liberals stammer, screech, and sputter with outrage if you ever, ever question their patriotism. But time and time again they give us reasons to, from blaming the United States for 9-11, to not supporting our troops, to sympathizing with our enemies, and idolizing men who exemplify everything that is anti-American, like Castro, Stalin, and liberals favorite hero, Che Guevara.

....

Liberals look at America, and have a hard time feeling the love and patriotism that conservatives feel because they can't get get past the flaws. They can't love America unless she is perfect. Conservatives, however, don't require perfection to know that America is, indeed, a special, blessed place. It doesn't mean that the rest of the world is a terrible, terrible place. It doesn't mean that no one can possibly have a great life anywhere else. However, despite what many Little League coaches and PC teachers may believe, not every runner can finish the race in first, and while the rest of the world may be great, it's just not the USA.

I think that last paragraph nails it.  Liberals are in love with an ideal, which can never be attained in real life. I've seen one sig file which begins, "I pledge allegiance to the Constitution..." suggested as an alternative to the salute of the American flag. The liberals who use this appear to me to be declearing allegiance to an ideal, which no country -- even the one whose Constitution it is -- has ever implemented to their liking.  Or ever will.

Sunday, November 16, 2008

The United Methodist Church and War

Matthew May at The American Thinker looks at the United Methodist Church's opposition to war -- unless it's their war against President Bush.
Denunciation of President Bush has emanated from seemingly all corners of the world. Few individuals or groups have matched the slurs, lies, and outright hatred that have come from officials of the United Methodist Church (UMC), which incidentally happens to be the church of George W. Bush. Official UMC has portrayed President Bush as a war criminal, wicked and wickedly ignorant; an object of derision unworthy of the church and its educational institutions. They have distorted and denied his accomplishments while distorting and denying the teachings of the founder of Methodism in a misguided and dishonest attempt to beat the president about the head for acting incompatibly with the philosophy of the denomination.
....
During a meeting in November 2001, at Lake Junaluska, North Carolina, the Council of Bishops debated and rejected issuing a public statement explaining the church's teachings on just war theory. Instead the bishops declared their neutrality in U.S. action against Osama bin Laden's organization and the Taliban in Afghanistan. Additionally, language introduced by two of the bishops to specifically request UMC members pray for men and women of the United States military was voted down; rather, the statement offered prayers for "people who have been placed in harm's way and their loved ones."[3] "People" could certainly have meant U.S. military personnel, but it could have also meant Osama bin Laden and his surrogates, no?

Not all of the bishops on the council reflexively ignored the denomination's teachings on just war theory or endorsed the explicit suggestions of other bishops that the United States was complicit "in creating some of the chaos," as did Bishop Ann Shearer of Missouri.[4] Bishop Tim Whitaker of Florida disagreed with such language that amounted to justifying terrorist acts and stale denunciations of American imperialism and oppressive foreign policy as if lifted from an SDS manifesto. Unfortunately, voices like Whitaker's were outnumbered and his ideas and thoughts, while politely considered, ended up on the cutting-room floor.
....
The United States is described within the Standards as "a sovereign and independent nation, and ought not to be subject to any foreign jurisdiction." As such, the 2004 letter argued that Iraq held the same status and rights as the United States "no matter what anyone's opinion is of its former head of state. Attacking a sovereign nation except in cases of legitimate self-defense is a violation of international law." Also notable was what the letter did not say about Saddam Hussein; that he harbored al-Qaeda terrorists (Abu Nidal, to name one), that he flouted the United Nations time and again, that he presided over murder, rape, and the execution of homosexuals among other acts about which some of us may or may not have an "opinion." In the eyes of the group proffering the petition, Hussein's Iraq and the United States stood on equal footing.

A neat trick, that. Such a formulation ignores that it was not President Bush's "opinion" that Saddam Hussein posed a threat to his neighbors, Israel, and the United States; it was the policy of the United Nations in the aftermath of the 1991 Gulf War in its various resolutions, which Saddam Hussein continually defied. Randall Hoven thoroughly decimates the left's arguments regarding the reasoning for invading Iraq to begin with here. Mr. Hoven points out that the president was not engaged in "cowboy" antics, but acting upon the written law of the United States as passed by Congress. As he writes: "The invasion of Iraq was arguably the most justified case of military action the US has ever taken in its history, based on national defense, validated intelligence and legal authority, not to mention morality.  Articles of impeachment would have made more sense if Bush had not invaded."

Notably, no such exhortations of repentance for causing violence in Iraq were put upon President Clinton by the United Methodist Church following his airstrikes against "sovereign Iraq" in December 1998, airstrikes that may be plausibly argued amounted to nothing more than an attempt to defect attention away from the House of Representatives voting to impeach President Clinton. On the contrary, the Detroit Annual Conference of the UMC - to cite one example - passed a resolution the following year that read, in part, "Military sanctions are reasonable policy in that they seek to contain the ability to create and use weapons of mass destruction."[5] Apparently it depends on who is ordering the military strikes on "sovereign nations" in deciding who is and who is not acting in defiance of the teachings of the New Testament.
....

The Founder

....
What left-leaning United Methodists hope you do not know or recall when they selectively lift passages from the writings of John Wesley in furtherance of discrediting conservatives or anyone else on the question of military action by this republic is that Wesley was a proponent of just war theory.
....
If a Christian denomination refuses to call true evil by its name yet remains comfortable promoting the idea that those who attempt to destroy that evil in the cause of freedom are worthy of its condemnation, how can anyone take the teachings within that denomination seriously? The United Methodist Church has been unable to get a basic moral absolute correct. History will not look kindly upon the deliberate acts of relativism, hypocrisy, inconsistency, and mean-spiritedness committed by the United Methodist Church on questions of its own theology, morality, and the responsibilities of the state in the face of grave threats and acts of war these past eight years. The shame of such behavior will never be expunged.

There's a lot more.  Read the whole thing, as they say.

Monday, July 21, 2008

U.S. or not?

Thomas Friedman looks at American power in the world, and whether the world would be better off without it.

Maybe Asians, Europeans, Latin Americans and Africans don’t like a world of too much American power — “Mr. Big” got a little too big for them. But how would they like a world of too little American power? With America’s overextended military and overextended banks, that is the world into which we may be heading.

Welcome to a world of too much Russian and Chinese power.

I am neither a Russia-basher nor a China-basher. But there was something truly filthy about Russia’s and China’s vetoes of the American-led U.N. Security Council effort to impose targeted sanctions on Robert Mugabe’s ruling clique in Zimbabwe.

The U.S. put forward a simple Security Council resolution, calling for an arms embargo on Zimbabwe, the appointment of a U.N. mediator, plus travel and financial restrictions on the dictator Mugabe and 13 top military and government officials for stealing the Zimbabwe election and essentially mugging an entire country in broad daylight.

In the first round of Zimbabwe’s elections, on March 29, the opposition leader, Morgan Tsvangirai, won nearly 48 percent of the vote compared with 42 percent for Mugabe. This prompted Mugabe and his henchmen to begin a campaign of killing and intimidation against Tsvangirai supporters that eventually forced the opposition to pull out of the second-round runoff vote just to stay alive.

Even before the runoff, Mugabe declared that he would disregard the results if his ZANU-PF party lost. Or as he put it: “We are not going to give up our country because of a mere X” on some paper ballot.

And so, of course, Mugabe “won” in one of the most blatantly stolen elections ever — in a country already mired in misrule, unemployment, hunger and inflation. Some 25 percent of Zimbabwe’s people have now taken refuge in neighboring states.

....

Which brings me back to America. Perfect we are not, but America still has some moral backbone. There are travesties we will not tolerate. The U.N. vote on Zimbabwe demonstrates that this is not true for these “popular” countries — called Russia or China or South Africa — that have no problem siding with a man who is pulverizing his own people. So, yes, we’re not so popular in Europe and Asia anymore. I guess they would prefer a world in which America was weaker, where leaders with the values of Vladimir Putin and Thabo Mbeki had a greater say, and where the desperate voices for change in Zimbabwe would, well, just shut up.

Friday, May 02, 2008

Tuskegee and History

Jonah Goldberg offers an account of Tuskegee that doesn't quite mesh with what "everybody knows".

So what did happen? In 1932, public health researchers set out to study syphilis, particularly among African-Americans, who had higher infection rates than whites. They recruited 399 black men who already had syphilis. The doctors infected no one. In fact, the patients were selected in the first place because they were tertiary-stage syphilitics who were no longer contagious.

The researchers studied the progress of the disease, without treating it, for 40 years.

Prior to the availability of penicillin in the 1940s and 1950s, the researchers couldn’t have treated the men even if they wanted to. Even after standardized penicillin treatments were available, it wasn’t clear that the patients could have been helped. Some of the doctors believed that treating the decades-long infections would kill the men.

Among scholars who’ve studied Tuskegee, there’s a lot of debate about how much — if any — racism was involved in the experiment. But no one disputes that Tuskegee had nothing whatsoever to do with genocide or even a desire to spread the disease among the black population.

What was bad about the Tuskegee experiment was a callous disregard for the humanity and integrity of the patients. They were told they were getting “treatments” when they were merely being studied. They were lied to, treated as objects rather than citizens. This is even more offensive today, now that we have modern legal and ethical rules about informed consent — rules that did not exist when the study was launched. But it was still wrong.

But the idea that the Tuskegee experiment somehow validates the deranged, paranoid view that the U.S. government created AIDS to murder African-Americans — in one of the most hideously painful, drawn-out and expensive manners imaginable — is a riot of ridiculousness and a maelstrom of mendacity. And yet, I’ve lost count of how many times I’ve heard guilt-ridden white liberals say exactly that. “Considering what we did at Tuskegee,” they opine, “who can blame them for being distrustful of government?

Tuesday, April 01, 2008

Prophetic or pathetic?

People continue to flock to defend the indefensible. In his sermons, Jeremiah Wright does to his congregants' minds what a few Catholic Priests have been doing to their congregants' bodies.

Now, what are some of the comments that are so widely deemed "prophetic?"

"We've bombed Hiroshima, we've bombed Nagasaki, we've nuked far more than the thousands in New York and the Pentagon, and we never batted an eye."

"We have supported state terrorism against the Palestinians and black South Africans, and now we are indignant. Because the stuff we have done overseas is now brought right back into our own front yards."

"America's chickens are coming home to roost. Violence begets violence. Hatred begets hatred and terrorism begets terrorism."

"The government gives them the drugs, builds bigger prisons, passes a three-strike law and then wants us to sing 'God Bless America'? No, no, no, not 'God Bless America,' 'God Damn America.'"

"The government lied about inventing the HIV virus as a means of genocide against people of color. The government lied."

How is this not prophetic? Well...

As morally disturbing as the Rev. Wright's comments are, and as troubling as is the fact that the man favored to be the Democratic Party's candidate for president of the United States chose to stay in the reverend's church for 20 years, there is something even more disturbing in the widespread labeling of these comments as "prophetic."

It is one thing to have a broken moral compass as do the Rev. Wright and those many Americans of all colors who also see America as a force for evil; who also believe immoral American behavior caused the slaughter of 9/11; who similarly regard America as morally equivalent to its terrorist enemies; and who see Israel as the moral equivalent of those who seek to exterminate the Jewish state. But to distort the biblical prophets' values to mean the opposite of what they actually mean is arguably an even greater sin.

The essence of the real prophets was not that they said things that disturbed people; the moral essence of the prophets was their moral clarity. They knew the difference between good and evil. "Woe unto those who call good 'evil' and call evil 'good,'" said the Prophet Isaiah.

Those who cannot see the monumental moral gulf between America and the unspeakably evil jihadists America is fighting in Iraq and elsewhere are not prophets. Those who think Americans got what they deserved on 9/11 are not prophets. Those who think the Russian people were better off under Communism are not prophets. Those who think America developed AIDS and infected people of color with it are not prophets. Those who think America is more worthy of damnation than of blessing are not prophets. They are fools.

So many times, when people are saying "prophetic", my ear tricks me into hearing "pathetic".

Yet, beyond the bad pun, this is a pathetic voice. Wright's sermons are rooted in pathos:

We are victims. We feel sorry for ourselves. It is your duty to feel sorry for us too, and bend over backwards to make us feel better.

We are victims. We are incapable of improving our own lot. It is your duty to lift us up, especially since you have kept us down all this time.

We are pathetic.

Monday, March 17, 2008

Can anyone make Wright right?

Okay, Show Us the Context That Makes Wright Look Not So Bad

....

What are you going to tell me about him that refutes the "God d*** America" line? What "full measure" am I going to see that makes me say, "oh, well, now I'm okay with his called for our nation to be damned by God.

Similarly, Obama seems to have felt it necessary to mention that Wright was a Marine in every interview. Great. That doesn't change the fact that he just called for God's wrath upon our own country. How many Americans will say, 'well, one balances out the other?'

It's like the line that Wright's comments are being taken out of context. Show me the context that makes that line okay, or the context that justifies the charge that the U.S. government created the AIDS virus.

How many people were calling for us to take Mel Gibson's antisemitic rant "in its full context"?

Thursday, July 12, 2007

Our enemies

Al qaeda and its allies hate us. This says good things about us.

Sunday, April 22, 2007

Withdraw the troops

From South Korea.

The US in Korea site is quite an eye-opener! Let's just start with the subject that got me there: teaching. The site makes it clear that KTU, with 90,000 members, isn't the mainstream teachers' group there, but it's hardly small or fringe.

This excerpt is pulled from an an essay, Teaching Anti-US/USFK Thought To Children, from the site. [USFK is U.S. Forces/Korea]

Then came revelations about a highly anti-American "lesson plan" - that contained many, many pages - located on the KTU website and distributed to its several tens of thousands of members. The blatant nature of the propaganda value of the "teaching" material also (thankfully) created a backlash, but — it found some sort of favor with President Roh Mun-Hyun. He criticized the plan intially, but then changed his mind after discussing it with his base of support - the one that carries as part of its platform a healthy dose of "bad America" and "USFK cancer."

Dennis Prager has suggested, in the light of anti-American sentiment in South Korea, we have a vote. If as few as one third of the South Korean population wants the U.S. troops to leave, then we pull them out and let them handle their own defense against North Korea.

We could probably offer most of Europe the same "deal".

Tuesday, November 15, 2005

Chemical Warfare in Iraq?

There's been a flurry of reports on the Web about accusations the US has used chemical weapons in Iraq. Specifically:

RAI, the all news state-run satellite channel in Italy, aired a documentary Tuesday that accused the United States of using chemical weapons against the civilian population during a November 2004 bombardment of Fallujah. AKI, the Italian news agency, reports that the documentary, entitled "Fallujah: The Hidden Massacre" and aired on the first aniversary of the assault on insurgents in Fallujah, includes interviews with former US soldiers and with residents of Fallujah who say that during the assault on the city the US military used the chemical white phosphorus.

...continued in full post...

The Daily Kos jumped all over the story, and there have been any number of comments elsewhere.


Scott Burgess, at The Daily Ablution, has some postings on the subject:

Here: Essentially, the injuries reported are not consistent with burns from white phosphorus.

One interesting comment:

Some have claimed the use of WP contravenes the 1993 Chemical Weapons Convention which bans the use of any 'toxic chemical' weapons which causes 'death, harm or temporary incapacitation to humans or animals through their chemical action on life processes'.

That means, tear gas is banned, but machine guns are OK.

Also,

(I can't help but feel that, if the smoke was in fact as dangerous as Mr. Monbiot wants it to be, the Organisation for the Prohibition of Chemical Weapons would take note).

And:

There are no reported deaths resulting from exposure to phosphorus smokes."
No "burning flesh to the bone", then. No "caramelisation" or "dissolving". No suffocation and "burning from the inside". "No reported deaths".

Here:

One good sign that you've done well in a discussion is the descent by your counterpart into the realm of the ad hominem. If, at the same time, he ignores the substantive, factual points you've raised (e.g., the opinion of his chosen expert that his conclusions are ill-founded), you're left with little choice but to conclude that he's incapable of answering those points. The Independent's Andrew Buncombe seems to be in precisely that position of impotence.

Here

Referring to another quote from yesterday's Independent story, I asked:
Daily Ablution: "Are burns caused by white phosphorus consistent with 'bodies burned but clothes intact'?" John Pike: "No

And finally, it seems witnesses on whose accounts this story is based have axes to grind.


Mudville Gazette has a lenthy post on Fallujah, including:

As for the rest, the BBC debunks many of the instant myths surrounding this story, noting that White Phosphorous is an incendiary weapon (also used to create smoke screens), not a chemical weapon, and that although the US is not a signatory to any international treaty restricting the use of white phosphorus devices the military has stated they were used to illuminate combat areas at night.

CounterColumn has a comment here and links to another comment here.

Tuesday, May 10, 2005

Politics and agendas

This is one of several springboards for some thoughts about politics. One comment about the Mommy Brain post included a mention, in passing, of the Equal Rights Amendment going down to defeat. At first, the comment blamed the "overwhelmingly white, male Congress" for voting it down. After another comment corrected the first (it died when too few states had ratified it when the time expired), the original commenter stated:

But I will say that it was the white, male controlled political process that didn't support it, so it failed.

...continued in full post...

Well, yes. At the time, the political system was overwhelmingly populated by white males. It was also developed and shaped almost exclusively by white males.

Nevertheless, I'll offer Ken Hamblin's challenge, which he used as the tile of one of his books: Pick a Better Country. Or in this case, pick a better system. I'd love to see a ranking by country of the rights and the standard of living afforded to women and minorities. It'd be interesting to group these countries according type of government. I'd be willing to bet that the highest-ranked countries would have systems of government developed by "overwhelmingly white, male" bodies. In fact, I'd be willing to bet quite a lot. (And I recall a commentary piece in Newsweek some years ago, bemoaning the fact that China, which was hosting the international Women's Rights Conference that year, had such a dismal record on women's rights. It occurred to me that darn few other countries would be any better. Indeed, their right to gather and discuss women's rights pretty much depended on their citizenship in countries, run by white, male governments.)

The authors of the linked article are accused of using their religion merely to advance a political agenda.

The Reform rabbi charged that when we oppose homosexual marriage because the Bible views homosexuality as a sin, we use faith merely to advance a political agenda. That is like saying that because he quoted Scripture while fighting segregation, Reverend Martin Luther King used faith to advance a political agenda. Civil rights was not any more a “political agenda” than is protecting the traditional family. They are both deep moral values. They may not be everybody’s moral values but they are ours. Politics is nothing more than a society applying its deepest moral values in a practical way. Without politics, citizens who disagreed with one another would resort to guns and knives. However the system of politics does depend upon treating with respect, even those with whom we disagree. Your labeling us as prejudiced bigots is not respectful. You may disagree with us, but we are as entitled to our beliefs as you are to yours. America grants freedom of belief to Bible-believing Jews and Christians as well as to secular fundamentalists.

"Politics" derives from a Sumerian word meaning "city". Politics is the set of techniques that allow people to get along with each other in large groups. When you get a group of people large enough to form a city, or at least a village, you need these skills. And there are lots of ways of getting people to work together. Some work better than others.

The Equal Rights Amendment may be gone, but the lot of women in the US is much closer to complete equality than it is in most of the world. The US government was developed by whites, but it affords blacks and other non-whites more freedom and opportunity than they have in most of the rest of the world. Indeed, blacks in particular are freer here than they are in most countries where they are the majority.

That politics is "a society applying its deepest moral values in a practical way" implies that any political system can be traced back to deep moral values. The sex and color of the founders of the US government matter, in the final analysis, much less than the moral values they used as the foundation for this government. Whatever anyone may think of the history of this country, its failings with respect to human rights, and the failings of its founders, one thing remains true:

The values on which this country were founded are good ones. Martin Luther King cited the Bible in his fight against segregation, but he also cited the Declaration of Independence. Many of his speeches were challenges for Americans to live up to the lofty values enshrined in that document. If the country is as racist and unjust as it's so frequently made out, the fact that it could be shamed into living up to "all men are created equal" says a lot for the founders' moral values.

Tuesday, April 12, 2005

Kristof on media

Here's a link to the Kristof piece. He complains about a number of trends he doesn't particularly like.

...the climate for freedom of the press in the U.S. feels more ominous than it has for decades. ...it's also crucial for us to reflect on why this is happening now - and a major reason, I think, is that we in the news media are widely perceived as arrogant, out of touch and untrustworthy. ...public support for the news media has all but evaporated.

Journalists who have been painstakingly "neutral" toward American culture are starting to realize what it means when American culture is "neutral" toward them.

In this kind of environment, it's not surprising that journalists are headed for jail. The safety net for American journalism throughout history has been not so much the First Amendment - rather, it's been public approval of the role of the free press. Public approval is our life-support system, and it is now at risk.

Anyone who's read various critiques of the press has heard about the lack of diversity. Milbloggers have pointed out that news articles frequently contain basic errors that would never have made it past anyone with even an ounce of military experience. But significantly, they make it past everyone in the newsroom.

We also need more diverse newsrooms. When America was struck by race riots in the late 1960's, major news organizations realized too late that their failure to hire black reporters had impaired their ability to cover America. In the same way, our failure to hire more red state evangelicals limits our understanding of and ability to cover America today. I think we're nuts not to regulate handguns more strictly, but I also think that gun owners have a point when they complain that gun issues often seem to be covered by people who don't know a 12-gauge from an AR-15.

Interestingly, especially given the title of Bernard Goldberg's second book on the press, Kristof writes:

If one word can capture the public attitude toward American journalists, I'm afraid it's "arrogant." Not surprisingly, I think that charge is grossly unfair. But it's imperative that we respond to that charge - not by dismissing it, but by working far more diligently to reconnect with the public.

Now this is extremely penetrating. It's imperative to respond to the charge of arrogance in some way other than by being arrogant.

Thursday, January 27, 2005

How things have changed...

John Ray wonders when American universities started going downhill.

STOP THE ROT

There is no question that leftist views have infiltrated our colleges and universities. But what most people may not know, is just how far left the pendulum has swung. Ben Shapiro is a recent graduate from UCLA. He is also the youngest syndicated columnist in the United States. What he says has crept into American universities is astonishing. Sharpiro said, "You go on campus, you pick up the campus newspaper and see editorials comparing Ariel Sharon to Adolf Eichmann. And then you walk outside class and you see the Muslim Student Association handing out pamphlets actively fundraising for Hamas and Hezbollah, and you figure, boy, I better do something about this." <snip> So how did our colleges and universities become havens for anti-American thought and rhetoric? Some say the Leftist agenda that is running rampant today got its roots in the 1960s. The radicals of the Sixties Revolution are the same men and women at the head of our educational institutions and are in charge of shaping the minds of our young people today.

When I was still in school, one of my teachers sounded off on the "radical college kids" who insisted on being taught only those things that were "relevant". And they wanted to be the ones to decide what was "relevant".

Sometime in the sixties, it seems the inmates took over the asylum.

Stripped of the connotations these words have to mental health, that statement is exactly correct. The original meaning of "asylum" is "shelter". People who come to the US "seeking asylum" are not trying to get themselves institutionalized. They want shelter.

A school is a shelter, within which learning and practice occur.

When I was in college, some of my fellow students took umbrage at the use of the phrase, "When you get into the real world," or any variant that implied college was not the real world. (Frankly, I did too, more because my friends were doing it, than because I'd thought about it.)

But college is not the real world. It's a place where you can learn things, and try out new skills and new ideas. With very few exceptions, you are shielded from the consequences of failure. After all, you can always retake the course next year.

And the term that is properly applied to those living inside a shelter is "inmates".

Some time in the sixties, it somehow became unfashionable for anyone to claim to have more knowledge, experience, or wisdom than anyone else. In particular, it was unfashionable for professors to claim to know better than students do. The fashionable egalitarian belief took hold among college professors and administrators, and as beliefs so often do, this belief caused people to behave in certain ways. In particular, when the inmates decided to take over the asylum, the staff stood aside and let them.

So far, the hard sciences have resisted, mainly because hard sciences are hard, with sharp edges. If you try to do something against the laws of physics or chemistry, the system has a way of biting you in the rear end. Hot glass has a way of reminding you that "hot glass" is more than just an arbitrary social construct.

Monday, January 10, 2005

Stingy americans, again

Dick Morris has some comments on American stinginess.

According to Nicholas Kristoff, of the New York Times, the amount of aid we give adds up to 15 cents per person per day. He counts another six cents per day from private philanthropy, leaving us trailing behind 22 other countries.

Of course, to get this number, Kristoff counts only the 2% of Americans' charitable contributions that are directly earmarked to foreign philanthropy. The total daily contribution of each American to charity is 2.19, and if even five percent of that goes to foreign countries, that's nearly double Kristoff's estimate.

The US also helps a lot just by being rich. Our trade deficit with the rest of the world represents $500 billion in cash going to foreign business owners around the world.

Morris has some suggestions for increasing the amount of help we provide to the world's poor:

Should we do more to help Third World nations? Yes. But increasing government-to-government foreign aid is not the way to go about it. We need to open our markets further to imports. With 4 percent of the world's population, we still have one-quarter of its wealth. Those supposedly compassionate liberals who advocate protectionism seem to think we should make a profit in our dealings with the other 96 percent of the world. They're wrong. We need to lower or eliminate our sugar, beef, clothing and other import quotas and to repeal our farm subsidies. We can afford to widen our trade deficit and to subject our farmers to fair foreign competition. But these private-sector, capitalist solutions to the problems of Third World poverty do little to get a liberal's juices flowing. If the aid doesn't come from the government, extracted by taxes from American families, it doesn't count.

Stingy Americans

(Hat tip: Clayton Cramer.)

You've undoubtedly heard how stingy we Americans are. You've also heard, no doubt, how we gobble up 80% of the world's resources (or is it 90%? One made up statistic is probably as good as any other), to support our 5% of the world's population.

We do consume a disproportionate share of resources, but we handle a disproportionate share of the world's defense. In battle against the bad guys, we provide a great deal of the armament, and a disproportionate number of our soldiers die.

And our hardware gives us the ability to project resources into disaster areas that is second to none.

Today, during an afternoon conference that wrapped up my project of the last 18 months, one of my Euro collegues tossed this little turd out to no one in particular: "See, this is why George Bush is so dumb, theres a disaster in the world and he sends an Aircraft Carrier..." After which he and many of my Euro collegues laughed out loud. and then they looked at me. I wasn't laughing, and neither was my Hindi friend sitting next to me, who has lost family in the disaster. I'm afraid I was "unprofessional", I let it loose - "Hmmm, let's see, what would be the ideal ship to send to a disaster, now what kind of ship would we want? Something with its own inexhuastible power supply? Something that can produce 900,000 gallons of fresh water a day from sea water? Something with its own airfield? So that after producing the fresh water, it could help distribute it? Something with 4 hospitals and lots of open space for emergency supplies? Something with a global communications facility to make the coordination of disaster relief in the region easier?

We're "stingy" because at first, we allocated only a small amount of money in "foreign aid" to the areas hit by the tsunami. I wonder how much it costs to dispatch an aircraft carrier? If you had to pay by the hour, what would the tab run? You've got fuel, depreciation, maintenance, and a highly-trained crew each of whom gets paid far less than he'd get in private industry for the same job.

One page shows the annual cost of running a nuclear aircraft carrier at $444 million. That's about $1.2 million per day, or $50,650 per hour.

I don't thinki that includes the cost of any aircraft on the carrier – it would make sense that those are costed out separately. I was just looking at the cost of operating a helicopter, and it runs anywhere from $1200 to $3000 per hour. Compared to aircraft carriers, choppers are cheap.

Fifteen million dollars in assistance? That's twelve and a half battleship-days, not counting aircraft. How many battleships have we sent?

Clayton does not include the comment from the "Hindi Friend". I think it's worth including.

"Can you let your hatred of George Bush end for just one minute? There are people dying! And what are your countries doing? Amazon.com has helped more than France has. You all have a role to play in the world, why can't you see that? Thank God for the US Navy, they dont have to come and help, but they are. They helped you once and you should all thank God they did. They didnt have to, and no one but them would have done so. I'm ashamed of you all..."

They say love is blind. So is hatred.

Now go read the rest of it.

Tuesday, November 30, 2004

A letter of apology

Here may be found a letter of apology.

I have a few items to add.

  • I'm sorry we suck up 80% of the world's resources, in exchange for 80% of the money the rest of the world receives.
  • I'm sorry we use those resources to produce more than 80% of the world's goods and services, including life-saving drugs and high-tech equipment.
  • I'm sorry the USA sheds 80% of the blood spilled in wars to free people from their own tyrants.
  • I'm sorry that the USA promotes and advocates such a high standard of conduct. It must emberass the living daylights out of so many countries when their own conduct falls short by such an amount that they don't even claim any interest in following it. I'm sorry we're among the few countries willing to even try to meet such a standard of conduct. I'm sorry that we, being human, fall short the sort of perfection so few even attempt.
  • I'm sorry the USA is such a horrible place that people spend all their resources, up to and including their lives, trying to get here from all those other countries to which this apology is sent.
  • I'm sorry the USA is willing to step forward and deal with bullies that leave the rest of the world trailing yellow liquid wherever they go.
  • I'm sorry the rest of the world, too frightened to express any anger to bullies, turn and call the USA a spoiled brat, and throw a temper tantrum and threaten to hold their breaths until we do what they want.
  • I'm sorry we had to be the first to set up a government conceived in liberty and dedicated to the proposition that all men are created equal.
  • I'm sorry we need to fight in wars to ensure that this government of the people, by the people, for the people shall not perish from this earth.

And to any who are offended by my apology or the one I linked to, I'm sorry you're such a crybaby.