Smith is the well-known “Peyote Case,” in which Scalia, for a 5-4 majority, adopted the most narrow possible reading of the Free Exercise Clause of the Constitution, concluding that the First Amendment’s ban on laws “prohibiting” the “free exercise” of religion stated a non-discrimination rule only. Government could not target specific religious practices for prohibition, and could not prohibit conduct because it is engaged in for religious reasons. But if a “neutral” and “generally applicable” rule had the effect of banning religious practice or religiously motivated conduct, that was not a law prohibiting the free exercise of religion.
Scalia’s reading of the Free Exercise Clause was not entirely implausible: There is at least a colorable argument from the text (and history) that the Free Exercise Clause states a rule about the formal content of government’s rules — that government may not adopt a law that, by its terms, prohibits religious exercise. But the better conclusion (as I argue in today’s piece, and at greater length in my academic writing on the topic) is that the Free Exercise Clause confers an affirmative substantive right to the free exercise of religion, unimpaired by government’s laws, and that this sometimes may indeed confer an immunity, specifically for religious conduct, from government’s usual rules. (What was less plausible was Scalia’s manipulation in Smith of the Court’s prior Free Exercise Clause precedents, which Scalia refashioned into rather unprincipled, incoherent exceptions to his refashioned rule.)
I argue that Smith is a positively perverse reading of the Free Exercise Clause: As the sphere of government expands, the sphere of religious liberty contracts. And it has proved unqualifiedly pernicious in its consequences.
Friday, April 17, 2015
Scalias Worst Opinion
Tuesday, March 31, 2015
Saturday, June 12, 2010
Making Drug Testing Inconvenient
I've always said if my employer started a policy of random drug testing, I'd start baking cookies for everyone. Chocolate chip poppyseed cookies are absolutely delicious, especially if I use the canned poppy seed filling from the Jewish section of the market. Now, culinary poppy seeds are P. somniferum, or opium poppy. They give the best flavor. So everyone who eats more than a quarter of a cookie tests positive on the next drug screening.
Now, over at Reason's Hit and Run blog, Jacob Sullum reports on a man who drank some tea and lost his job after a drug screening.
We recently received a letter from a reader who says he lost his job as a truck driver for a trash and recycling company where he had worked for more than two decades because he tested positive for cocaine in a random drug screen after inadvertently consuming some of his wife's coca tea. He notes that the Department of Transportation's drug testing guidelines (PDF) specify that "consumption of coca teas" should not be accepted "as a basis for verifying a cocaine test result as negative." Far be it from me to defend the ridiculous drug testing policies that have been foisted on employers by the federal government, which in this case (as in many others) led to a patently unfair result for an employee who posed no threat to anyone. But the rule regarding coca tea makes sense from a prohibitionist perspective.I wonder what kind of flavor it would give to cookies...
According to a 1996 study reported in Forensic Science International, "the consumption of a single cup of Peruvian or Bolivian coca tea produces positive drug test results for cocaine metabolites." The reason is straightforward: Coca tea contains cocaine; coca is where cocaine comes from. So this is not, strictly speaking, a "false positive." Since coca leaf, like cocaine, is a Schedule II substance, coca tea is illegal in the United States, although you can buy it online and customs agents often let it through. It is not safe to assume that the leaf in these teas, like the leaf used to flavor Coca-Cola, has been "decocainized," and distributors are cagey on this point.
Monday, May 10, 2010
Casualties of the drug war
Commenter GeoffyG on police who justify shooting dogs or homeowners because they were responding "aggressively" to the band of armed men pouring through the door:
"Do we really want to live in a country where when someone busts into your house at night you're supposed to assume they might be cops?"
You may have to. If you defend yourself against intruders who turn out to be cops, you're in jail for assaulting police officers.
"The war on drugs is over. The Constitution lost."
Tuesday, April 13, 2010
Marines disrupt opium harvest
Jerry Pournelle argues, and I tend to agree, the way to handle this is not for the US to disrupt the harvest but to buy the Afghan opium crop. This would not only deprive drug makers of a major source for raw material, but it would give the Afghan farmers the income they need, and give them a reason to work much more closely with US interests.
This is especially true if US marines are any good at protecting Afghan farmers from drug dealers who are liable to be irritated at the loss of their raw materials.
Marines disrupt opium harvest
Marines are mounting an intensive effort to disrupt the opium harvest in the former Taliban enclave of Marja by confiscating tools from migrant workers, compensating poppy farmers who plow under their fields and collaborating with Drug Enforcement Administration personnel to raid collection sites.
The steps amount to one of the most novel U.S. attempts to crack down on a key part of Afghanistan's drug trade while seeking to minimize the impact on individual farmers, many of them poor sharecroppers who face economic peril if they cannot harvest or sell their crops.
The plan to pay farmers, who will receive $120 for each acre of tilled fields, prompted a tense debate among Marine officials and civilian reconstruction personnel, some of whom argued that it provides preferential treatment to those in Marja who planted an illegal crop.
But the Marines' program eventually won the approval of Secretary of State Hillary Rodham Clinton. In a March 30 cable to the U.S. Embassy in Kabul, she called the effort "the best decision in the face of an array of less-than-perfect options."
The Obama administration ended a program to eradicate poppy fields, saying it would drive farmers into the hands of the insurgency. Instead, the military and DEA operations here have been directed toward catching traffickers and drug kingpins and toward interdicting shipments of opium and processed heroin.
...
Marja, a 155-square-mile area in Helmand province, remains home to the country's largest concentration of poppy fields. Leaving them alone did not make sense to the Marines.
Even if the Marines had done nothing, the farmers would probably have faced serious difficulties. In the past, an estimated 60,000 migrant workers descended upon Marja to help with the harvest, but many might not come this year because more than 3,000 U.S. and Afghan forces are in the area. Also, the opium bazaars, where farmers sell their crops, have been shuttered.
The Marines have said they will block main roads and turn back migrant workers arriving for the harvest, due to begin within a matter of weeks.
To avoid discriminating against those who did not plant poppies, the new program is open to all farmers in Marja. But poppy farmers do not have to prove they did not harvest their opium, only that their fields have been plowed under. Marine officials believe cash-strapped poppy farmers will be the program's principal beneficiaries.
Those are people the Marines need to win over if Marja is to become stable. "If we hadn't done anything, we'd be fighting farmers at a time when we need to establish governance," said John Kael Weston, the State Department political adviser to the Marine brigade.
...
As of Sunday, 730 farmers had signed up, Marine official said. Payments will be made only after U.S. or Afghan security forces verify that the land has been plowed.
Afghan soldiers and police, backed up by Marines, have begun setting up checkpoints on access roads to Marja to dissuade migrant harvesters from entering the area. The security forces intend to confiscate any harvesting tools, Marine officials said.
....
We have never really done much to stop the harvest before despite media suggestions to the contrary. This program is probably the best we can expect in the current environment. Cutting off the transit routes out of Marjah seems like the best way to dealing a blow to the Taliban.
Tuesday, August 18, 2009
Big Pharma and Cats that Bark
Megan McArdle responds to a couple of questions from comments.
I feel that we are really getting somewhere in this discussion. I have two basic questions here. The first is this: if Megan thinks the Dutch system is fine apart from the price controls on drugs, why don't we adopt the Dutch system but not the price controls on drugs? If Megan's problem with the House insurance reform bill is not the actual House insurance reform bill, but the prospect that it will ultimately lead to price controls on drugs, why doesn't she back the House insurance reform bill and insist that it not adopt price controls on drugs?
The second question I have is this: if the House health insurance reform bill is so bad for drug innovation and research by pharmaceuticals companies, why are the pharmaceuticals companies buying $12 million in ads promoting the House health insurance reform bill?
The answer to the first question is simple: we can't. The political logic of pharmaceutical price controls is nearly overwhelming. You have a product that has a very low marginal cost and a very high fixed cost, which means that you can force them to provide it cheaply and eat the fixed costs if you have enough market power. You've got program that is rapidly turning into the sucking chest wound of the US budget. And you've got a big line item supplied by companies that are unpopular--unlike the other major players in the system, like doctors, nurses, assorted health care workers, and the local hospital. This is why most of Europe has turned to some form of price controls.
...in this case, I think it holds: price controls are a feature of national health insurance schemes, just as log-rolling is a feature of democracy. We might hold out for a while. But eventually, we'd have a combination of populists in office and a budget problem, and the pharma profits would go.
As for the second question, this is where I realize that liberals often really just do not grok what libertarians are about. For them, this is a battle between people who like health care companies, and want to defend them, and people who like the government. But I don't care about the pharmaceutical companies qua pharmaceutical companies. The pharmaceutical companies are interested in what is good for pharmaceutical companies. I am interest in what is good for society.
I am not under the delusion that those are necessarily the same thing. "What's good for General Motors is good for America" was a Great Society slogan, not a libertarian, or even a conservative one. Right now, pharmaceutical companies spend a great deal of effort on innovation because they have to in order to survive. But if survival means ditching the R&D labs and churning out low-cost copies of things they've already invented, then I'm pretty sure that's what they'll do. To paraphrase Adam Smith, it is not to the benevolence of pharma that I look, but to its self interest. In the current system, that self interest means inventing new drugs.
....
I'm not sure the cognitive gap between liberals and libertarians can be bridged. At the very least, as long as they think of us as defending corporate interests, rather than defending a system that most often aligns corporate interests with ours, everything we say will continue to seem vaguely puzzling.
Wednesday, June 17, 2009
Give me a blog!
Jacob Sullum has a nice column in this month's Reason magazine debunking the idea that guns purchased in the US fuel the drug violence in Mexico."Making it harder for Americans to buy guns is not likely to stop Mexican gangsters from arming themselves. The persistence of the drug traffickers' main business, which consists of transporting and selling products that are entirely illegal on both sides of the border, should give pause to those who think they can block the flow of guns to the cartels."He also argues, as I have, that conservatives who oppose gun control should also oppose the drug war. A war on drugs inevitably becomes a war on guns.
Sunday, April 19, 2009
Banning smokes
But if we must ban products to protect kids from smoking...
"I salute you for doing a great job," he began. "The only thing I wonder is . . . why don't we amend this to say that no person shall sell tobacco?"
Friday, December 19, 2008
Going to pot?
Like Mark Draughn, I've been somewhat skeptical of Barry Cooper, the former drug cop turned pitchman for how-to-beat-the-cops videos. He comes off as more of a huckster than a principled whistle-blower, which I think does the good ideas he stands for (police reform) more harm than good.
But damn. I have to hand it to him. This might be one of the ballsiest moves I've ever seen.
KopBusters rented a house in Odessa, Texas and began growing two small Christmas trees under a grow light similar to those used for growing marijuana. When faced with a suspected marijuana grow, the police usually use illegal FLIR cameras and/or lie on the search warrant affidavit claiming they have probable cause to raid the house. Instead of conducting a proper investigation which usually leads to no probable cause, the Kops lie on the affidavit claiming a confidential informant saw the plants and/or the police could smell marijuana coming from the suspected house.
The trap was set and less than 24 hours later, the Odessa narcotics unit raided the house only to find KopBuster's attorney waiting under a system of complex gadgetry and spy cameras that streamed online to the KopBuster's secret mobile office nearby.
To clarify just a bit, according to Cooper, there was nothing illegal going on the bait house, just two evergreen trees and some grow lamps. There was no probable cause. So a couple of questions come up. First, how did the cops get turned on to the house in the first place? Cooper suspects they were using thermal imaging equipment to detect the grow lamps, a practice the Supreme Court has said is illegal. The second question is, what probable cause did the police put on the affidavit to get a judge to sign off on a search warrant? If there was nothing illegal going on in the house, it's difficult to conceive of a scenario where either the police or one of their informants didn't lie to get a warrant.
....
The story's worth watching, not only to see if the cops themselves are held accountable for this, but whether the local district attorney tries to come up with a crime with which to charge Cooper and his assistants. I can't imagine such a charge would get very far, but I wouldn't be surprised to see someone try.
If this happened as portrayed, the police can't get a pass on it. Police officers have a great deal of power. If they're perceived as abusing it, public distrust will make their jobs infinitely harder.
Monday, August 25, 2008
Approving Drugs
Instapundit has a post wondering if the FDA is getting too cautious about approving new drugs.
IS THE FDA getting too cautious in drug approvals? If it is, people will die who shouldn't. But it's less likely to get blamed.
Years ago, I think it was John Campbell who proposed that we license quacks. (Um... "Practitioners of Alternative Medicine".)
Anyone who had an unapproved medical treatment could hang out a shingle and treat people, provided:
1) The licensed quack could only claim to be licensed as a quack – he could not claim any legitimacy for this treatment, or any sort of sanction except that the Medical Establishment knew this person was practicing.
1A) Above all else, there was no guarantee that the treatment offered by the licensed quack would improve whatever condition was being treated. Indeed, it could even make things worse. That's the risk you take by going to a quack.
2) Licensed quacks were required to keep careful records of all patients they treated, and the outcomes of treatment. These records would be made available to medical researchers on request, with reasonable restrictions intended to safeguard patient privacy. (Though sacrificing privacy might well be another cost of going to a quack.)
The reason for provision 2 was that if a new and unapproved treatment turned out to work, the evidence would be in the practitioner's records. True, without a control group, it might not be as solid as we'd like, but if Witch Hazel cures 50% of her cancer patients, and the national average cure rate for the same cancer is only 30%, that would be enough to attract researchers willing to set up a proper study.
Maybe a similar thing could be done with drugs.
The FDA could institute several levels of approval. The highest level would be the standard adhered to nowadays: the FDA guarantees the drug is at least as safe as doing nothing, and more effective than a placebo, and (apparently) no side-effects that could prompt litigation.
Lower levels of approval could be implemented, with higher levels of possible risk, down to "licensed snake oil" which has no guarantees except it does contain oil from snakes, and that if it turns out to work, whoever's selling it has been required to keep records that will show that fact.
So cancer patients could buy FDA approved shark cartilege, or FDA approved laetrille, or FDA approved whatever else is being offered. Because all of these would be licensed as "snake oil", there would be no guarantee that any of these things would actually work, or even be safe to ingest. They would contain real, certified laetrille, shark cartilege, or whatever, but whether they do anything is not the FDA's problem at that level.
Just a thought.
Wednesday, June 18, 2008
Legalize All Drugs
John Stossel says this over at Townhall.com.
His reasons, with which I tend to agree are:
After years of reporting on the drug war, I'm convinced that this "war" does more harm than any drug.
Independent of that harm, adults ought to own our own bodies, so it's not intellectually honest to argue that "only marijuana" should be legal -- and only for certain sick people approved by the state. Every drug should be legal.
and
While drugs harm many, the drug war's black market harms more.
And most importantly, in a free country, adults should have the right to harm themselves.
He feels compelled to deal with some myths of the drug war, including:
Myth No. 1: Heroin and cocaine have a permanent effect.
Truth: There is no evidence of that.
Myth No. 2: If you do crack once, you are hooked.
Truth: Look at the numbers -- 15 percent of young adults have tried crack, but only 2 percent used it in the last month. If crack is so addictive, why do most people who've tried it no longer use it?
Myth No. 3: Drugs cause crime.
Truth: The drug war causes the crime.
....
In turn, some buyers steal to pay the high black-market prices. The government says heroin, cocaine and nicotine are similarly addictive, and about half the people who both smoke cigarettes and use cocaine say smoking is at least as strong an urge. But no one robs convenience stores for Marlboros.
Friday, December 16, 2005
It's the Cheese!
Eating cheese may cause you to test positive on a drug test.
AN INTERNATIONALLY recognised test for cocaine is flawed - and can throw up positive results from powdered milk and parmesan cheese, say scientists. Laboratory research shows that the "Scott test" can fail to detect the drug in some samples and can wrongly identify it in some substances where no cocaine is present.
Police agencies have been using this test as a preliminary test, and anyone who tests positive may be a guest of the county jail until the results of a mass-spectrography test come back.
Tuesday, July 05, 2005
Winning the drug war
In many martial arts, you learn to "go with the flow". You defeat your opponent by flowing with his attack, joining it, and re-directing it in tge direction you want to go. Your opponent throws himself against the floor.
Here, a conservative Christian proposes to end the drug war, and take a huge bite out of the drug crime problem by apparently giving in. He would have us not only legalize drugs, but sell government-certified pure drugs in the marketplace.
Let's look at the demand problem this week. That's the easy one because it can be solved by government decree: Just get Congress to pass a law legalizing drugs and setting up super-discount outlets for heroin, pot, and other flavors of dunce drugs, and – poof! – the game is 90 percent over.
...continued in full post...
The Libertarian Party has advocated legalization for years. It's easy to accuse the Party of being made up of druggies and would-be druggies. Somehow, it seems harder to make that label stick to someone whose book is the darling of the Religious Right. Maybe his credentials will get people to listen to the reasoning behind legalization, which includes:
With legalization,
The magic of the forbidden fruit will evaporate, especially if President Bush decides to skip the government emporiums and sell exclusively through churches. (At least that would beat bingo and bake sales as a fund-raiser.) Envision this remark in a circle of teens slouched around your TV set on Saturday afternoon: "Hey, guys, let's go buy some crack from Father O'Toole and get high tonight." Approximately 12 seconds after the sale, your phone would ring with the news, and you and the other parents would come down on your kids like an avalanche down Everest.
Would increased availability mean increased use? Not necessarily.
Think back to the 1920s. Marijuana could often be found growing wild down by the river in most states, and all the kids knew what it would do if you smoked it, but no child with any social standing would have anything to do with a loser who was brainless and pathetic enough to try it more than once. That, I suggest, would soon become the prevailing attitude again if we demystified drugs by putting them where they'd be readily available – albeit, perhaps, attached to a sermonette.
How about kids going around the established stores to avoid stigma?
Would this social stigma push our young people back to buying on the street? Not often. The risk of doing time for selling a $5.95 baggie for $9.95 (tops) in an alley would be a strong motivation for going into used car sales or joining the French Foreign Legion. Besides, who would pay extra to get potentially fatal or sugared-up junk when the government-guaranteed pure stuff is so cheap? The whole drug mystique would dwindle into silliness and dissolve in ridicule. Who wants to be the butt of Leno two-liners?
Besides, how often do we have that problem with kids buying booze on the street? There's some, but how much? Here's a parallel case, and we should be able to derive some real numbers. What are they?
Another case the Libertarian Party makes is that the effect of the drug war (increasingly intrusive search-and-seizure laws, random drug testing, second-guessing of physicians who prescribe certain medicines, asset forfeiture laws, and so on) is worse than the problem it's trying to address.
Any good arguments otherwise?
Tuesday, April 19, 2005
Fact of the day
(From the daily e-mail for The Scotsman.com, April 16, 2005)
An interesting side-effect of a chemical called lysergic acid diethylamide is discovered today in 1943 as Dr Albert Hoffman accidentally takes the first 'acid trip' after ingesting some synthesized 'LSD-25' through his fingertips. Initially used as an aid for treating mental disorders, LSD soon became a popular drug with hippies in the 60s and is still widely used - or abused - today.
Now that's a flashback.
Tuesday, March 08, 2005
Corporate moral police
Dennis Prager has been discussing (and I believe intends to write his weekly article about) how Boeing has fired its president and CEO for adultery. The adultery took place on his own time. (Wizbang links to this article.
In a similar case, another company has adopted a policy of firing employees who smoke cigarettes on their own time.
I remember, years ago, Dr. Dean Edell would declare himself amazed at how we meekly surrender our urine and hair for drug testing, even though the drug use found was frequently away from work, on the employee's own time, and is detectable well after the effects have worn off.
The theory behind drug testing is that the cost of drug use is great enough to justify these invasions of privacy, and besides, if you don't want to be tested, you can work someplace else.
I don't advocate a law requiring or forbidding workplace testing. Indeed, I don't advocate laws requiring or forbidding any idiotic employment practice, as long as the employee has the option to leave. Instead, let consumers punish companies by taking their business elsewhere.
However, we see the effect of the slippery slope in action. When employers started demanding urine and hair samples to detect drug use, no one complained. (Well, some did, but not nearly enough.) Now, the precedent for testing for tobacco use is established. And if private adultery is a firing offense, does that justify hiring private detectives to follow employees around and take pictures?
What, if anything, is ruled out?
Tuesday, January 25, 2005
Drug sniffing dogs and other invasions of privacy
Orin Kerr comments on one of the latest Supreme Court decisions. The Court upheld the use of drug-sniffing dogs to find illegal drugs.
One aspect of the law which strikes me as troublesome has to do with the definition of what the Fourth Amendment protects.
The mercifully short opinion for the Court by Justice Stevens relied heavily on Stevens' own 1984 opinion, United States v. Jacobsen, which had held that the police do not conduct a "search" when they perform narcotics tests because narcotics are illegal contraband; interfering with a person's drugs does not violate their Fourth Amendment rights because Fourth Amendment rights in illegal narcotics cannot be constitutionally "reasonable." While this may seem a bit odd at first, it actually has substantial roots in existing law: as I argued in a recent article, a "reasonable expectation of privacy" is not the same as the expectation of privacy of a reasonable person, but rather is a term of art keyed heavily to property law. Because a person cannot have a property right in narcotics, the thinking goes (whether rightly or wrongly), interfering with his drugs does not infringe a property right and therefore does not constitute a search.
I wonder. How far could this reasoning be extended? Could a court rule that a person doesn't have a property right in stolen property, and so a warrantless search of property for stolen property does not constitute a search? Why or why not?
I've had a bit of a debate with Eugene Volokh about one issue that appears in this decision:
One interesting aspect of today's opinion is that Justice Stevens had to distinguish the Court's 2001 thermal imaging case, Kyllo v. United States, in which Stevens had dissented. Kyllo held (more or less) that it is a search for the police to point an infrared thermal imaging device at the exterior wall of a private home. To reconcile the holding of Place with Kyllo, Stevens reasoned that the key was the nature of the information that surveillance method yielded. The thermal imaging device was used to obtain intimate details in the home, whereas the drug-sniffing dog only indicated the presence or non-presence of illegal narcotics. ... In particular, dogs can sniff narcotics from the exterior of a car because the bags holding the narcotics are not perfectly sealed; some of the drugs leak out into the open, and the dogs can smell that. In the language of Stevens' Kyllo dissent, this was "off the wall" surveillance, not "through the wall" surveillance. But Stevens had no room to make this argument after Kyllo, so he had to focus on the nature of the information obtained rather than the way the search was conducted.
In the debate, the subject was radiation monitors which might be used to find nuclear weapons hidden somewhere in a city. The question was, could you use radiation detectors to locate a cache of fissile material in someone's home?
(Eugene referred to "Geiger counters", but these, and indeed, any gas-filled detector, are not the best instruments to use to find fissile material.)
Eugene spent a great deal of energy on the issue of how a non-directional radiation detector could be used to obtain information about what's going on inside a private dwelling. In the case of a person using a radiation monitor, he could stand on the street outside an address and measure levels of ambient radiation. Such a monitor is usually not directional, though with some effort it could be made directional. (Moving it from one side of the car to the other would give you some spatial discrimination, for example.) Absent any built-in or improvised directional resolution, the investigator would have to move the instrument from place to place and observe how ambient levels changed. At best, he'd be able to show that radiation levels rose as you got closer to a particular address. With this information, you could obtain a search warrant. You are not building an image of the distribution of radiation sources inside the building. Or, if you want to build a plot of radiation levels and call that an "image", it is one with resolution that is coarser than the size of the building involved.
A thermal imaging device, on the other hand, builds an image using infrared radiation which penetrates the wall of a building. It is a device which is capable of directly recording very precise spatial information in an area that is inside the boundary of private property. The image it can be used to create has a resolution that is finer – by a good margin – than the size of the building.
Maybe that's the ticket.
As long as the smallest object you can resolve with whatever imaging/detection technology you have is larger than the boundary of the private area you are searching near, it's OK to use that particular imaging/detection technology to obtain information about what's going on inside that area.