Showing posts with label Dennis Prager. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Dennis Prager. Show all posts

Wednesday, January 26, 2011

Political Correctness

Ultimate Issues hour today (11/9/10) dealt with Political Correctness, and Dennis' theory about why the phenomenon exists.

Dennis defines PC as the denial of painful truths. His springboard for this definition was a letter to the editor in response to his essay in the Jewish Journal, "Are People Basically Good?"

He discusses this letter in his response:

"Most revealingly, Mr. Beckmann writes, 'What a sad world it would be if we all believed as Dennis Prager that mankind is inherently evil.'

I did not write that man is inherently evil. I wrote that he is not basically good. And, yes, that does make the world sad. So do disease, earthquakes, death and all the unjust suffering in the world. But sad facts remain facts. A distinguishing characteristic of liberals and leftists is their aversion to acknowledging sad facts (the Soviet Union wasn’t evil; Islam has no more moral problems than Judaism or Christianity; the Palestinians don’t seek Israel’s destruction; there are no inherent differences between boys and girls, just sexist upbringing; the United Nations isn’t a moral wasteland, it’s mankind’s greatest hope; the list is almost limitless)."

Balint Vazsonyi wrote that political correctness originated under Communism, and the term was devised to distinguish "politically correct" things from "factually correct" things. The whole point of "politically correct" is that it refers to things that are *not* factually correct. A political correctness is something which we agree to claim, even though at some level we know it's not true. (Or at the very least, we fear it might not be true?)

One symptom of PC is that when someone goes against PC, the response is one of indignation, and taking offense. In short, one "strikes a nerve". When you strike a nerve in a discussion of purported truths, I think that's a sign you've wandered afoul of someone's notion of PC.

Now to the morsel that provokes my comment here. Dennis claimed that PC exists only on the left. I suppose that's a reasonable belief, particularly if Mr. Vazsonyi has correctly identified the origination of the term. Something invented on the left may be supposed to have stayed on the left. However, I suspect the notion that PC exists only on the left may itself only be politically correct. I can think of at least a few examples of things which provoke the same sort of indignation that Dennis saw in response to his piece. Nerves are just as easily struck on the right as on the left.

I could mention evolution, but I wont. (Oops, I guess I just did. "This is not the Droid you are looking for.") I actually have another example of a topic that strikes Dennis right on an exposed PC nerve: IQ.

Dennis doesn't seem to like the notion of IQ. When "The Bell Curve" came out, he expressed considerable outrage at the notion that people might actually believe in differences in IQ, and he was most especially outraged at the notion that people actually believed different races might have different average IQs.

His argument has been along the lines of: 1) There is no difference between races, so there can be no difference in average IQ between races.
2) IQ doesn't mean anything.
3) If someone claims to find a difference in average IQ, this finding is either wrong (see point 1) or meaningless (see point 2).
4) Anyone who fails to see the validity of the preceding three points is SIXHIRB.

As a result of this PC attitude, the question, "what if there are real differences" may not be asked or considered in any way. The absolute homogeniety, as opposed to equality, or different racial and ethnic groups is taken as an article of faith, because believing otherwise is just not PC.

Tuesday, May 18, 2010

Fwd: [NC-Prager Group] Going Wobbly


Following is a rather lengthy response to points raised during Dennis Prager's interview woth George Friedman (STRATFOR).

I won't say Friedman's failure to address the points raised here are necessarily lethal. In a broadcast hour, there is an average of 33½ minutes of actual broadcast time, the rest being ads, news, and station breaks. Intro, re-intro, lead-in and lead-out takes another minute or two. If you're a BBC news presenter, trained to speak at 120 words per minute, we're looking at the equivalent of a 3800 word article. Nobody reaches this speed in an interview.

That being said, I'd love to see Friedman address these points in a forum where he has the time.

Going Wobbly

One reason I've never been able to warm up to Stratfor is the persistent gloominess and despondency it exudes. George Friedman and his mopy men must have published an optimistic analysis of some world event somewhere, somewhen; but danged if I can recollect any. For the most part, any Stratfor paper can be reduced to the following abstract: Doom is nigh!

Victory is never an option

Lately, however, the entire organization appears to be in utter despair. Take today; Friedman was a guest on Dennis Prager's radio show, and he made the following points:

  1. We cannot possibly stop Iran from getting nuclear weapons; it's inevitable.
  2. Even without nukes, Iran's conventional forces mean it can dominate the entire Middle East at will.
  3. If we were even to try to take out Iran's nuclear sites, it would mine the entire Strait of Hormuz; this would stop 25% of the world's oil market from flowing, which would raise oil prices beyond $400 or $500 a barrel... which would utterly destroy all Western economies, including our own.
  4. There is nothing Israel can do in response to a Hezbollah chemical attack except hunker down and hope that some of Israel's population survives. Hezbollah probably cannot kill every Israel; some would surely remain.

From these "realistic" (that is, terminally pessimistic) assessments and analyses, Friedman made the following recommendation, near as I can recall. This is of course my own phrasing, not Friedman's; but I believe it amounts to a reasonably fair summary of what it appeared to me Friedman proposed:

Since the United States is pulling out its troops, we have no power at all in the Middle East anymore. Israel cannot help us, and we cannot help Israel. Therefore, the only course of action available to us is to cut a deal with Iran.

Since we have no power to threaten Iran, we'll have to accept whatever terms Iran dictates. We will have to recognize and acknowledge Iran as the ruling player in the Middle East; if we're contrite enough, Iran may allow us to have the oil we need to survive.

As for Israel, it must cut the best deal it can with Hezbollah and hope that some Israelis will be allowed to depart in peace. America's moment is passed; the Young Turks (and Persians) will be the new masters of the world.

Friedman went on to predict, following a second question from Prager, that the European Union was fated to shatter apart. Most of Europe will sink into the State of Nature described in Hobbes' Leviathan, where those few remaining lead lives that are "solitary, poor, nasty, brutish, and short." However, some countries will do very well: Germany will probably prosper; but the biggest winner will be Russia, which will end up ruling all of Europe, eastern and western.

We must cut a deal with the Russian bear as well. But see, at least we get a choice: America can become a client state of either Russia or Iran!

Needless to say, I find such despair mongering less than convincing. I note that George Friedman left a number of circumstances out of his calculations.

Iran's deathgrip on the world's oil supply

First, he never once mentioned the staggering oil wealth we ourselves have, right here in our own backyard. Besides the Gulf of Mexico, the Santa Barbara coast, and ANWR -- which by itself comprises nearly as much oil as in all of Iran, and not counting the 20 billion barrels of oil (bbl) we already have at our disposal (should we ever choose to dispose of them) -- we also have something in great abundance that most members of OPEC have scantily or completely lack: oil-shale deposits.

The four largest oil-shale reserves are in the United States; combined, they're the equivalent of more than two trillion bbl. By way of comparison, the combined liquid oil reserves of Saudi Arabia, Iran, Iraq, Kuwait, the UAE, Venezuela, Russia, Libya, Nigeria, Qatar, Algeria, Brazil, and Mexico are less than 1.2 trillion bbl.

So a better way to phrase Friedman's point 3 above is that, if we take out Iran's nukes, then inexplicably allow them to mine the Strait of Hormuz without a fight, we would be forced to begin drilling in our own vast territory -- and selling oil to our allies, who could no longer travel to the Persian Gulf. (Of course, that means we would get those trillions of petrodollars, instead of Iran; what a shame!) And if the price indeed rose sufficiently, it would spur us to begin extracting oil from shale, inventing whatever techniques are necessary to make it practical and profitable.

Not to mention giving us a real incentive to develop high-temperature ceramic engines to burn gasoline much more efficiently, something I've been writing about since the halcyon days at Patterico's Pomposifications, half a decade ago.

Then there's coal liquifaction, nuclear fission, solar-power satellites, and many other energy sources that don't require us to kow-tow to our enemies, begging them to supply us with oil. The current system is untenable anyway: Why entrust our entire economy to countries that would as soon see us dead as the proverbial clam?

Instead of using our energy fragility as an excuse for doing nothing in the face of threats and provocations, murders of our troops and aiding and abetting our enemies... why not use our weakness as a spur towards complete energy self-sufficiency? That's the American way of responding to an impossible situation: change the rules of the game to allow us to win!

Rather than being a deal killer, Iran's threat can turn out to be an utter game changer... pushing the United States to a much stronger position of world leadership even than we enjoy today. It's not a setback, it's a challenge.

Military muscle

Likewise, Friedman's burbling threnody of despair assumes that if Iran decides to mine the Strait, there's nothing we can do about it. If we try to attack Iran's missile and nuclear sites, we'll fail. If Hezbollah shoots Scuds with chemical warheads at Israel, the Jewish state can only cower in the dark and wait for Armageddon.

He seems to have little faith in American, Israeli, and in general Western fighting spirit. I have greater.

Some years ago, I discussed a military strategy for use against Iran that I dubbed the Herman Option, after historian Arthur Herman, who wrote about it. Here is an extensive excerpt from that 2007 post...

Take a moment to look at this map of the Persian Gulf:

Persian Gulf

Iran: Persian Gulf and Strait of Hormuz

The narrow pinch of the Strait of Hormuz on the far right of the Gulf -- about 20 miles wide, with two 1-mile wide sea lanes for tanker traffic -- controls delivery of about a quarter of the entire world's daily oil production. It is staggeringly important to the entire world.

The biggest fear about Iran is that, in response to an attack on their nuclear development sites, they might strike back with a catastrophic terrorist attack in the strait: Iran, Hezbollah, or both could attack an oil supertanker at the narrowest part of the strait, sinking the huge ship and sealing the passage for perhaps years... and as a serendipitous side effect, causing the worst environmental disaster in human history (I'm sure the Iranian mullahs lose sleep over that one).

There is reason to fear this option: the Iranians themselves have practically boasted about it. In Arthur Herman's Commentary piece linked above, he notes this quite matter of factly:

In April of this year, as if to drive the point home, Iranian armed forces staged elaborate war games in the Gulf, test-firing a series of new anti-ship missiles capable of devastating any tanker or unwary warship. In the boast of one Iranian admiral, April's "Holy Prophet war games" showed what could be expected by anyone daring to violate Iran's interests in the Gulf. A further demonstration of resolve occurred in August, when Iran fired on and then occupied a Rumanian-owned oil platform ostensibly in a dispute over ownership rights; in truth, the action was intended to show Western companies—including Halliburton, which had won a contract for constructing facilities in the Gulf—exactly which power is in charge there.

A 30-page document said to issue from the Strategic Studies Center of the Iranian Navy (NDAJA), and drawn up in September or October of last year, features a contingency plan for closing the Hormuz Straits through a combination of anti-ship missiles, coastal artillery, and submarine attacks. The plan calls for the use of Chinese-made mines, Chinese-built missile boats, and more than 1,000 explosive-packed suicide motor boats to decimate any U.S. invasion force before it can so much as enter the Gulf. Iran's missile units, manned by the regime's Revolutionary Guards, would be under instruction to take out more than 100 targets around the Gulf rim, including Saudi production and export centers.

As Herman notes, "contingency" plans are just that, and may never come to fruition; but clearly, Iran is thinking along these lines. And why not? How could they more seriously hurt the West than to shut off the black gold (Teheran tea) that we depend upon? (I'm sure the mullahs have followed with great glee the GOP's bootless efforts to open up a teensy-tiny fraction of the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge (ANWR) to clean, modern oil extraction... along with the Gulf of Mexico and the California coast; the efforts were of course thwarted by the then-minority Democrats, who were rewarded for their intransigence by being voted into the majority.)

But on the other hand, as the saying goes, "a plan betrayed is a plan denied." The Persian Gulf is a two-edged scimitar. Herman again:

Every country in Western Europe and Asia, including those that complain most bitterly about American policy in the Middle East, depends on the steady maintenance of the global economic order that runs on Middle Eastern oil.

But -- and herein lies a fruitful irony -- so does Iran itself. Almost 90 percent of the mullahs' oil assets are located either in or near the Gulf. So is the nuclear reactor that Russia is building for Iran at Bushehr. Virtually every Iranian well or production platform depends on access to the Gulf if Iran's oil is to reach buyers. Hence, the same Straits by means of which Iran intends to lever itself into a position of global power present the West with its own point of leverage to reduce Iran's power -- and to keep it reduced for at least as long as the country's political institutions remain unprepared to enter the modern world.

On a nutshell, Iran thinks of the PG as the lever by which it will move the world; but in reality, to a truly modern nation such as the United States, the Gulf is the lever by which the rest of the world will move Iran.

Herman suggests a seven-point plan to break the logjam with Iran:

  1. Announce that we will not tolerate any nation interfering with the flow of oil through the Strait of Hormuz;
  2. Back that threat up by sending at least a carrier battle group (CBG) to the Persian Gulf, along with anti-submarine ships and planes (the latter are routinely carried on carriers), minesweepers, Aegis Ballistic Missile Defense System-equipped cruisers and destroyers, UAVs, and our own submarines;
  3. Declare a one-country blockade of all of Iran's oil shipments out -- and gasonline shipments in; a complete freeze-out. Everyone else gets to ship freely through the strait... just not Iran;
  4. Launch a "comprehensive air campaign" against Iran's air defenses, air bases, communications grid, and missile sites along the PG;
  5. Continue the campaign against the nuclear sites and all supporting infrastructure, including roads, bridges, power plants that serve the nuclear development centers at Natanz and Bushehr, and so forth;
  6. Finally, and most important, continue the campaign to take out all of Iran's gasoline refineries.

Herman points out the critical choke-point for Iran and the focus of this campaign:

It is still insufficiently appreciated that Iran, a huge oil exporter, imports nearly 40 percent of its gasoline from foreign sources, including the Gulf states. With its refineries gone and its storage facilities destroyed, Iran's cars, trucks, buses, planes, tanks, and other military hardware would run dry in a matter of weeks or even days. This alone would render impossible any major countermoves by the Iranian army. (For its part, the Iranian navy is aging and decrepit, and its biggest asset, three Russian-made Kilo-class submarines, should and could be destroyed before leaving port.)

Contingent upon the completetion of the first six steps, Herman suggests the coup de grĂ¢ce:

  1. American special forces would seize all of Iran's offshore wells and pumping stations, from the strait to Kharg Island (the small, unmarked island just off Iran's coast, due east of Kuwait and about 10 o'clock from Bushehr).

Herman concludes that if we did all this, we would able "to control the flow of Iranian oil at the flick of a switch."

While it's clear Iran threatens to mine the Strait if we attack, it's by no means a sure bet that it will succeed; in fact, we have a very good counterstrategy at our fingerends, the Herman Option. In addition, Iran would be cutting its own throat -- which means the very threat itself may be nothing more than a monumental bluff.

There is yet another George Friedman dog in the night that doesn't bark. When discussing Hezbollah and its chemical-tipped Scuds, why did he never even mention the possibility of missile defense? For heaven's sake, has anyone thought that it might possibly have occurred to Israel that Syrian Hezbollah could shoot missiles at them from Lebanese territory?

I strongly suspect that Israel has invested a lot of time and treasure in developing anti-missile systems, particularly for fast, short-distance use -- from Lebanon to Tel Aviv, for example. What logic in assuming that all or even most of the missiles will successfully strike their targets?

But beyond missile defense, would Syria really risk such an aggressive move into all-out, existential war, knowing that in such a dire circumstance, Israel would not make any distinction whatsoever between Hezbollah terrorist targets in Lebanon -- and Syrian military, C3I, and political targets in Damascus?

Deterrence still deters, especially when dealing with a non-jihadist, eminently practical king such as Bashar Assad.

Knowing what is at stake -- that is, what will be at stake, when we have a new Commander in Chief in 2013 -- I believe Iran's and Syria's deeds will not quite live up to their invective. Mahmoud Ahmadinejad talks a great fight.

George Friedman obviously knows all of this; but his interlocutor, Dennis Prager, probably does not, nor does most of Dennis' audience. Shouldn't Friedman have mentioned the positive side of the ledger? Alas, he did not; he limned only the gloomy, pessimistic part of the painting. It's hard not to conclude that he has an agenda... and a good understanding of the whole picture would just get in the way of "the fierce urgency of now."

It all boils down (as oft it doth) not to some technical measure of strength or military might, but rather to our will to fight. And it's exactly that "will to fight" that despairing, defeatist analyses directly attack: If we think we can't win, defeat becomes a self-fulfilling default position.

"Fear is the mind killer."

"Fear is failure and the forerunner of failure."

Fear is a living thing: Feed it, stroke it, heed it, and it grows; starve it and it weakens and dies. Honestly, we need more Petraeuses and a lot fewer George Friedmans; I'm afraid the one of the latter we have plays directly into the hands of our Cowardly Lyin' president.

Expect the exeptional

All this whining and whimpering like whipped dogs is unbecoming the world's only hyperpower. Such despair is not only illogical, not only plays into our enemies' hands, but most important, it's unAmerican. Only those who voluntarily surrender can be ultimately defeated; that is the deepest secret. So long as we stand and fight our fate, Fate is unbound.

Should we go gentle into that bad night? Or should we burn and rave at close of day? If you're an American, there's no need to ask; when the time comes, we'll know what to do. And it will never include signing a suicide pact with Iran to buy us a few more years of subjugation.

"Rage, rage against the dying of the light."

Monday, August 10, 2009

Media interviews

Michelle Malkin gets letters.

This one is from a pediatrician who was interviewed by the Washington Post, and was a bit dismayed at what they did to her statements.

I couldn't believe that these are the quotes which ended up in the paper. The first wasn't even close to what I said. I never referred to Rep. Hill by his first name and the "effigy" comment was not even close to what I was talking about. I mentioned how I "wouldn't hang him in effigy" (since that is the left's favorite thing to do, ie, Sarah Palin, Bush), meaning that I have concerns, but am willing to voice them in a productive way. He also asked me about how I've been trying to get people involved and I mentioned that I have posted things on FB to encourage my friends to contact his office.

He came into my home with his agenda, a very liberal agenda, and I gave him the benefit of the doubt. I thought that he would present both sides equally and fairly, and instead twisted my words and did not even put the important things in that I had emphasized. I always believed that the left had their agenda and always knew that they would warp our views to better fit how they want the world to see us. Now, my beliefs have been validated. I'm sick over this. Here is the link to the article.

Dennis Prager has stated he records all of his talks and lectures.  Other people have taken to having audio recording equipment (if not AV) present during press interviews.

Fortunately, recording equipment is cheap these days.

Thursday, July 30, 2009

Prager motto

Just heard on the radio:

"If you can't call a black fool a fool, you're the racist."

Sunday, June 07, 2009

E pluribus unum

In Dennis Prager's video, he sets forth what he considers the American Trinity of values that set us apart from everywhere else in the world.  One of these is E Pluribus Unum -- "Out of many, one".  This is the value which states that, ideally, we don't care where you're from or what your ancestry is, you can become one of us.

Ilya Somin reflects on this value in a post just written today:

Less often appreciated are the ways in which life for immigrants in America is much better than in most other affluent liberal democracies. Although the US is not free of racism and nativist xenophobia, on the whole immigrants are much better accepted by natives than in almost all of the many other countries I have seen. We take it for granted that a person born in Russia or China or India can become as much a "real American" as the descendants of the Founding Fathers. Yet such ready acceptance is far less common elsewhere. In trips abroad, I have seen Russian immigrant communities in several countries, including France, Germany, and Israel, and spoken extensively with relatives and other Russians living there. In each case, they are less assimilated, worse off economically, and have much more tense relations with native-born citizens than the Russians who have come to the US over the last several decades.

Friday, October 03, 2008

Prager's bumper sticker experiment

Dennis Prager has a quasi-bet (because he claims not to be a gambler) over which vehicle would be subject to more vandalism: one parked in a liberal neighborhood with a conservative bumper sticker, or one in a conservative neighborhood with a liberal bumper sticker.
Ed Morrissey at HotAir has one answer -- at least this sets a bar for vandalism.

Tonight, as we prepare for our Debate Party tonight at Trocadero's, one of the listeners for our radio station AM 1280 The Patriot has to prepare for some hard work cleaning his work van and personal car.  He made the mistake of thinking that he could have a bumper sticker showing his support of the station without thugs vandalizing his vehicles.  At least he remains in high spirits, as he e-mailed the station with the subject heading, "The Power of a Patriot Bumper Sticker":

I thought you might find these photos interesting. I've attached photos of the way I found my van this morning. Evidently, leaving a car parked on the street with Patriot and McCain bumper stickers is intolerable to Obama supporters. They didn't remove the sticker from my wife's Volvo, though. However, it appears that someone in my neighborhood didn't like it. Luckily, they didn't use permanent spray paint, just some really annoying stuff that was hard to wash off.

Now, what kind of people would put this much energy into defacing other people's property simply because they had Patriot and McCain bumper stickers on one of the cars?  Usually, the same kind of people who screech constantly about "tolerance" and the closed-mindedness of Republicans.  Fraters Libertas has more.

Now: how many examples of this being done to a van with liberal bumper stickers can we turn up?

Debate: Prager v Sirota

On September 22, 2008, Dennis Prager and David Sirota sat down to a debate.
He didn't want to name his opponent, because he felt a need to preserve the person's dignity.
Unfortunately, a person, armed with a good search engine and a key phrase or two, can find an amazing array of things on the Web.
This debate has been blogged here and here by The Greasy Rag (conservative),
and here at The Farr View (conservative),
and at Kenneth Davenport's blog (conservative).

The opening remarks are on YouTube (a DVD will be available sometime this month).

David Sirota has a web page and a blog.
His comments about the debate are recorded at OpenLeft.

Monday, June 25, 2007

The rape of a name

(Warning: Link above is to an MP3 file.)

Last week, Dennis Prager spent an hour discussing his thesis that "the rape of a name can be as bad, or worse, than actual rape of the body."

Of course, this round of that topic is in response to what happened to the Duke University Lacrosse players. Not only did their families have to spend significant chunks of their inheritances defending them from charges that turned out to be false, their names and faces were splashed all over the New York Times, and they were labeled rapists by the District Attorney and a piano-full of professors (eighty-eight kiesters) at Duke. Fortunately for them, the fact that they were found innocent (not just "not guilty") was also headline news.

Dennis comes to this sort of situation with a statement from Judaism: He who publically humiliates another is regarded the same as if he had shed that person's blood. In other words, to harm or destroy a person's reputation is the same as harming or destroying that person.

He spent an hour on this topic because he's gotten any number of e-mails differing with him. There are any number of people who, at least on first thinking about it, have decided being physically raped is worse than having one's name dragged through the mud. This is even true for some of his callers.

Then he started getting calls from people who have seen the aftereffects of both. One person cited the statistic that many women refuse to report their rapes, because the damage to their reputation is more painful. (This may not be entirely valid – a woman may reasonably decide ten units of pain is enough, and she doesn't want to face the eleventh.)

And then the most telling caller was a woman who had been raped, and later had been accused of molesting one of her children. She stated the rape of her name was much worse.

So, after all that, we get to the point I want to discuss. Dennis was quite puzzled that one's reputation had come to be held so lightly, when in the past it was known to be extremely important. I think he's missing a bit of historical perspective.

In the past, when just about everyone lived in small communities, everyone knew everyone else. Whatever you did followed you around, often for the rest of your life. If you screwed up, your only option was to hope you could "live it down" – spend the next however many years atoning, and particularly doing very much other than what you had done to earn your reputation, so that people would come to disregard your past.

You could, of course, pick up and move to another village, if you had the freedom to move from place to place (many people were bound to the land and not free to leave). You also had to be willing impoverish yourself (money existed, but most people didn't have any, and there were no banks, especially none with branches in other cities). In effect, you had to abandon your life in one village, and trek to another one where you wouldn't be known.

And since you were an unknown in the new village, you would be forever regarded with suspicion. The process of relocating was hard enough that people only did it for very pressing reasons – like escaping a major stain on their reputation. You could probably not count on living long enough to be an accepted member of your new community.

With increasing freedom of movement, and with the increasing ability to pick up and move from one place to another, it became easier to outrun a reputation. If a person had learned his lesson, and mended his ways, it was actually possible to sail to a new country, or drive to a new state, and start a new life. There were enough people around who had done just that to make any other person who did so – well, not that strange. (And in places like the Foreign Legion or California mining towns, everyone was from somewhere else.) It became possible to outrun a reputation.

Fast forward a few years, and we have the anonymity of the big city. In a small town of a few hundred, it's possible to know everyone personally. In a small town of a few thousand, it's conceivable that everyone will be known by reputation. In a city of a hundred thousand or a few million, forget it. Most of the people you run into in a big city will be strangers, and chances are, you'll never see them again. Your reputation is whatever you do in the seconds or minutes you're interacting. Reputation is something you share with a fraction of the people you meet.

To be sure, it's possible for someone to attain "repute". People can become famous, or infamous. Paris Hilton has a reputation, as does Kato Kaelin. (Remember him? I only remember him because he's in an ask.com spot.) Or, you can be made famous against your will, like the Duke Lacrosse Players.

Part of being a member of a Global Village is that any reputation you have, or any reputation that is created for you, can be spread far and wide, whether you want it so or not. In your preindustrial village, your reputation was based on what you did, and word of it spread to everyone, for good or for ill. But villagers had limited power to shape another's reputation. If someone made up lies about others, enough people would compare the stories with the actual facts to earn the storyteller the reputation of a gossip. There were some incentives to watch what you said about others.

But now, in the global village of the 21st Century, our cultural institutions and our sensibilities have lagged behind our power to spread information. Anyone can say anything about some other person, and post it where a Google search will find it.

Now, the insult one school child posts about another in her MyFace blog will probably not be counted as highly significant by a prospective employer doing a Google search. But I guarantee those Lacrosse players will have the tale of their rape charges following them forever. Every time someone does a Google search on their names, that story will come up. Thousands of links will pop up.

To be sure, Mike Nifong is no longer an attorney, and he's likely to die in poverty after he loses the lawsuit from the families of the three players. His reputation is now carved in digital stone. But no one in the justice system is proposing that Crystal Mangum (Janette Rivers) suffer any sort of penalty for what she did.

Back in the days when reputations were harder to run away from, laws developed to help safeguard them. In Jewish law, for example, the penalty for bearing false witness (in court) was that the one bearing false witness would be sentenced to the penalty the subject of the falsehood would have gotten, had the lies been believed. Crystal Mangum should be sent to prison for the same length of time the Lacrosse players would have had to serve, had they been convicted. If she's suitably remorseful, maybe she could be allowed to serve those terms concurrently. But she did serious damage to the reputation of the three defendants, as well as to the rest of the Lacrosse team. She also did serious damage to the credibility of anyone who steps forward with an accusation of rape. Her case will now be cited as proof that women do, sometimes, lie about being raped.

We're in a culture now where we can't run away from a reputation any more, and our laws have to allow us to protect them, or else we'd better forget our cultural and evolutionary past and learn that reputations don't mean anything.

Tuesday, December 06, 2005

Five answers from a Muslim

A while back, Dennis Prager asked five questions for muslims. In the linked article, Maher Hathout, senior advisor to the Muslim Public Affairs Council and a spokesman for the Islamic Center of Southern California, offers his answers.

Some of his answers are extremely interesting.

...continued in full post...

"Why are you so quiet?"
Like an urban myth, the idea that Muslims have been mute since 9/11 plagues us. Prager knows that mainstream Muslims have issued condemnations of terrorism ad nauseam, and American Muslim scholars even issued a fatwa against terrorism this summer. ... The problem isn't how loud we are but how deaf some people can be.

Prager, commenting on this piece, noted he should have made this question less amgiguous. For example, "Why are there no demonstrations among the billion Muslims of the world against terrorism?"

This would have been nice, but I think the original quesition is adequate. "Why are you so quiet?" When children in an Israeli pizza parlor are blown up, someone issues a lukewarm denunciation. When the news reports that some non-Muslim may have actually had physical contact with a Koran (so-called "desecration"), riots ensue. Why does a Dhimmi fingerprint on a Koran provoke a riot, and Muslim suicide bombings of children only rate a stern memo?

"Why are none of the Palestinian Christians terrorists?"
Beyond the seemingly deliberate tone of cynicism here, Prager seems to forget that the current spate of suicide attacks was initiated by the Munich Olympics tragedy, which was concocted by a non-Islamic group led by a Christian named George Habash. There is nothing about being Muslim that leads to terrorism. The premise is wrong; so is the conclusion.

One Christian suicide attack, compared with how many Muslim suicide attacks? Declaring the premise wrong does not make it so. Now answer the question.

Why is only one of the 47 Muslim majority countries a free country?
But let's not forget that the colonial powers that dominated these countries found it easier to deal with the dictators they installed than with masses intent on creating their own destiny. Our country is not completely innocent on this score.

Fails to address the question. Many non-Muslim countries are free, or are in the process of becoming free. In many cases, former colonies are freer and richer than their neighbors, because they inherited the English language (useful for international trade) and notions of democracy from their colonizers. But this point forms an interesting contrast to the next answer:

Why are so many atrocities committed and threatened by Muslims in the name of Islam?
Yes, criminals are exploiting the grievances of depressed, oppressed and desperate masses in order to try to justify the unjustifiable. But finger-pointing won't get us anywhere.

Does this include pointing fingers at former colonial powers? Or countries that have invaded other countries to depose dictators and stop the filling of mass graves?

His final point, though, starts to hit the target, and suggests some other questions:

What we need now is to enable robust, mainstream Muslim organizations to expose this minority, isolate it and rid us of this scourge. Casting doubt about Muslims only adds to the haze and confusion that allow extremists international prominence. Innuendo only makes it less likely that any religion will be respected or its followers accepted.

Question: What would enable these robust, mainstream Muslim organizations to "expose this minority, isolate it and rid us of this scourge"?

Finally:

Why do countries governed by religious Muslims persecute other religions?
What makes you so sure they're "religious Muslims"?

Um... how about the fact that no "robust, mainstream Muslim organizations" have taken any visible steps to "expose this minority, isolate it and rid us of this scourge"? When a contestant in a beauty pageant says Muhammed might have married one of the contestants, there are riots. When this woman is threatened with death for daring to use Muhammed's name in that context, someone writes another stern memo.

I'm not absolutely sure myself, but based on the available evidence, I know what conclusion I'm inclined to draw.

Tuesday, November 15, 2005

Five questions for muslims

THE RIOTING IN France by primarily Muslim youths and the hotel bombings in Jordan are the latest events to prompt sincere questions that law-abiding Muslims need to answer for Islam's sake, as well as for the sake of worried non-Muslims.

The questions?

(1) Why are you so quiet?

When Muslims object to something, they demonstrate. There are demonstrations over any number of things. When a lady in a beauty contest said any of the women in the contest was someone Muhammed would have been happy to marry, there were riots.

When suicide bombers blow up children in restaurants, there are no demonstrations.

(2) Why are none of the Palestinian terrorists Christian?

There are significant numbers of Christians in the Palestianian territory. But only Muslims engage in terrorist acts.

(3) Why is only one of the 47 Muslim-majority countries a free country? According to Freedom House, a Washington-based group that promotes democracy, of the world's 47 Muslim countries, only Mali is free. Sixty percent are not free, and 38% are partly free. Muslim-majority states account for a majority of the world's "not free" states. And of the 10 "worst of the worst," seven are Islamic states. Why is this?
(4) Why are so many atrocities committed and threatened by Muslims in the name of Islam?

Google "honour killings" some time. Daniel Pearl was kidnapped and killed – his head sawed off with a knife. In the name of Allah.

(5) Why do countries governed by religious Muslims persecute other religions? No church or synagogue is allowed in Saudi Arabia. The Taliban destroyed some of the greatest sculptures of the ancient world because they were Buddhist. Sudan's Islamic regime has murdered great numbers of Christians.

Also, read "From Time Immemorial" for a history of how dhimmis have fared under Muslim rule.

Tuesday, May 24, 2005

"How do we Know?"

(An open letter to Dennis Prager)

June 15, 2001

(A very old open letter)

Dear Dennis:

This letter is inspired by several recent (within the past few months) topics on your program. These are the topics of the Moon Landing Hoax video, God and the Astronomers, and Evolution.

This is a rather long message, and I apologize for its length. Basically, the points raised are as follows: http://ritestuff.blogspot.com/2005/05/how-do-we-know.html

1) Despite the unreasoned opposition to the big bang theory, it eventually became the accepted doctrine, because of the weight of evidence.

2) Although the weight of evidence shows that the moon landings took place, most people choose to believe or disbelieve it because of their preconceptions about the credibility of sources.

3) Not all evolutionists are atheists. Most of the scientists who accept evolution are believers. When Darwin first propounded evolution, the accepted doctrine throughout the scientific world was creationism. Evolution came to be the accepted doctrine the same way the big bang theory did: the overwhelming weight of the evidence was in its favor.

4) The call to "present both sides" of the argument is a cop-out at best, and deliberate deception at worst. Consider how you'd react if your school decided to present "both sides" of World War II, and invited the Institute for Historical Review in to give a seminar to the pupils. Sometimes there's a good reason why proponents of an established doctrine are arrayed against those with a different point of view.

5) Your brother's example of rocks spelling out "hello, how are you" is only superficially compelling.

All of these topics have a common theme, which is "how do we know what we know", and "how do we decide what to believe."

...continued in full post...

Most people seem to take positions on any number of matters, not because of having examined the facts, or the arguments for and against, but based on how compatible these positions are with core beliefs and prejudices. An example you gave is the reaction the astronomical community had to the notion of an expanding universe.

God and the Astronomers

Your explanation for the opposition was an emotional rejection of the very idea that the universe might have had a beginning, and therefore might have a creator. I can think of another explanation, namely that astronomers were still wedded to Aristotle's notions of a perfect, unchanging universe. (Einstein, confronted with an expanding universe implied in his own equations, added a "fudge factor" to make the universe stationary. He later described this as the worst blunder of his career.)

However, one thing I would like to call to your attention: the big bang theory is now the reigning doctrine in astronomy. Nobody proposes going back to the steady state theory to avoid the possibility of the universe having had a beginning.

Why was the big bang theory accepted, despite initial opposition? Because the overwhelming weight of evidence was in its favor. Once people knew what to look for, they found that all the evidence pointed to an expanding universe.

Did we land on the Moon?

As you know, the Fox network presented a video making the case that the Moon landings were faked. The program made a case which is superficially very compelling, but only because all the evidence showing the landings were real was excluded, and the few facts that made it on film were heavily reinterpreted to support the hoax theory.

When you stop and examine the issue, though, the evidence that the moon landings were real is so solid, and from so many different sources, that it's perverse to continue to discount it. Provided, of course, you accept the sources as authoritative. If you happen to believe that the government is engaged in a vast conspiracy to pull the wool over all our eyes, you might decide that every source except for this one video is lying.

The issue is very simple. The moon landings happened, or they didn't. There is no in-between. But who has the time, or the energy, or the ability, to check out all the claims and counter-claims?

Evolution

The same questions apply to the subject of evolution. Again, as a statement of objective fact, either all life is descended from a single ancestral organism, or it isn't. Either the first living thing arose through natural processes, or it didn't. Either life as we know it came to be the way it is through processes found in nature, or it didn't.

Support for evolution, and opposition to "creation science" is sometimes due to opposition to religion, to ascribe all support for evolution to anti-theist sentiments is to slander the millions of evolutionary biologists who are devout, believing Christians, Jews, Moslems, etc. Many, indeed most, believers are perfectly content to believe in a God who created the rules of the universe such that their blind, mechanistic functioning would have been designed to give rise to life and all the complexity we see around us today.

Indeed, the antipathy to evolution that I see in "creation scientists" and "intelligent design theorists" is just as telling in its own way as the rabid anti-theism of people like Richard Dawkins. It seems almost as if the anti-evolution crowd is terrified of science. They fear that as scientific discoveries reveal the natural causes of everything around us, their reasons to believe will be annihilated.

When Darwin proposed his ideas, the entire scientific establishment believed that life came to exist through special creation. The diversity of life and the intricate order of nature were seen as the result of the divine hand. Biology's place was to examine the natural order and learn what God had in mind when He was creating the world. (Back when science was called "natural philosophy", scientists felt they were learning the mind of God from His creation.)

What about all the problems with evolution?

When Darwin first proposed his ideas, special creation was the dominant belief. Darwin's singular idea was not just the idea of natural selection, although that is a major idea. His major idea was the notion that processes that could be observed in nature were sufficient to explain the diversity of living things. This idea has been expanded over time, and the current doctrine holds that processes that can be observed in nature are sufficient to explain the origin of life itself.

From the very first, many people elucidated what they saw as problems with the theory. A famous argument is known as "Paley's watch argument". If you saw a pocket watch on the beach, the argument runs, you'd immediately recognize it as a manufactured thing. The simplest living thing is more complex than any watch, so it must be even more necessarily a designed thing.

The problem with this argument is twofold: Firstly, we have experience of watching people build watches, as well as a variety of other mechanical devices. Secondly, as research continues, we have accumulated experience of watching molecular systems, and even intricate molecular machines, self-assemble. The physical properties of molecules and their environment drive this self-assembly. Natural processes can accomplish a lot.

Nowadays, science finds that the processes that exist in nature are uniformly sufficient to explain everything around us, sooner or later. The problems Michael Behe expounded upon in his book, "Darwin's Black Box", have begun to fall to persistent investigation. The elaborate blood-clotting mechanism evolved from a much simpler one-step mechanism through gene duplication and subsequent differentiation of functions. The flagellum started out as an excretory system, and only later became useful for movement. I have no doubt that when the visual chain reaction is examined, it will prove to contain derivatives of proteins that exist elsewhere, in slightly modified forms.

Behe's likens the evolution by natural processes of the machinery of a cell to jumping across a mile-wide chasm. He represents naturalistic explanations as akin to claiming that stepping stones rose from the floor of the chasm long enough to allow a person to cross, and then retreated. In fact, what we see is that where now exists a chasm, there was once a bridge, and the bridge has since fallen down. After he calls our attention to the problem, we do the equivalent of shining a searchlight down the chasm, and what do we find? Pieces of a bridge scattered across the bottom. All of a sudden, the presence of people on the other side of the chasm is a lot less mysterious.

Can we prove that the mechanisms proposed for the development of vision, blood clotting, and so many other intricate systems are the ones that were actually used? No we can't. By the same token, in the example given in the last paragraph, we can't prove that the people on the other side of the chasm used the bridge whose pieces lay at the bottom. But the existence of the fragments of the bridge seriously weaken the need for the hand of God to carry people across this gap.

"Presenting both sides"

Often the claim is made that we need to present both sides of certain issues. Many who wish to teach creationism in public schools appeal to an "equal time" argument. It's only fair, they say, to give the other side a chance to present its case. But is it really fair to dump this sort of debate in the laps of schoolchildren before they've acquired the tools needed to sift through conflicting claims?

What if, instead of, say, the Creation Research Institute calling for equal time for creation, we saw the Institute for Historical Review (IHR) calling for equal time for its view of the Holocaust? Is it fair to ask school kids to come to their own decisions based on the IHR's presentation and however much time the school can bring to bear in rebuttal? If we bar the IHR from presenting its case in schools, they can certainly cry censorship. Do we give in and let them have their say? Or maybe we can take the approach so many schools have taken with evolution - skip the subject entirely.

Messages in the rocks

Your brother uses the example of a person walking along, coming upon the rubble from a land slide, and finding a bunch of rocks that spell out the message, "hello, how are you?" If you saw something like that, you'd have to conclude that an intelligence was at work. As it happens, I've seen that countless times. In fact, there's a gravel pit near my home that has just such messages. All I have to do to prove it is remove all the rocks that aren't part of the message.

I'm only half kidding here. A lot of the basis of "intelligent design theory" is meaning assigned after the fact, and very bad estimates of odds for and against events.

Your brother's implied argument is that the development of life is equivalent to a number of rocks falling off the side of a mountain and landing so that they line up to form a message, and nowhere else. No serious student of evolutionary biology believes that scenario. The accepted scenario is much more like my example, where rocks have peppered the landscape, and some of them form a message. The problem lies in identifying what sort of selective mechanism will remove rocks that aren't part of a working message.

We don't know all the details yet, but if I were to place a bet on the outcome, I'd bet that a workable path from chemicals to living things will eventually be drawn without recourse to any supernatural forces.

Atheists will be comforted (?) by this lack of reliance on anything beyond the pale of nature; theists will be able to regard this as the result of an exquisitely designed system of laws.

Friday, April 29, 2005

The marriage debate

Peter Wood takes on the American Anthropological Association's statement that:

The results of more than a century of anthropological research on households, kinship relationships, and families, across cultures and through time, provide no support whatsoever for the view that either civilization or viable social orders depend upon marriage as an exclusively heterosexual institution.

One of the contributions to the notion that heterosexual marriage is only one of many different, equally valuable, forms of marriage, we have:

Last April, John Borneman, an anthropologist at Princeton, and Laurie Kain Hart, an anthropologist at Haverford College, published an essay in the Washington Post purporting to find in the history of anthropology a mandate for gay marriage: "Does marriage have to be heterosexual? The human record tells us otherwise." As proof, they cite a well-known East African case, in which a woman pays the brideprice of another woman and officially claims her as a "wife." The trouble is that this "marriage" is only a legal fiction, not a lesbian coupling. Borneman and Hart clearly knew that, but buried the explanation in an opaque observation that "This role of wife is above all social, and not contingent on her sexual relations."

As I mention here, I happened to hear an interview between Dr. Borneman and Dennis Prager. Near the end of the interview, Dr. Borneman offered what he considered to be a generalized anthropological definition of marriage. In essence, the only common factor in all the institutions he classed as "marriage" was "the transfer of a dependency relationship from one family group to another."

I sent Dr. Borneman an e-mail pointing out that under this definition, "marriage" would also include such institutions as fostering and legal adoption. In his reply, he agreed, and called my e-mail one of the more intelligent ones he'd received on the topic. (Flattery will get you everywhere.)

Of course, such a broad definition has some drawbacks. For one thing, if your definition of a thing is so broad that anything can be covered by it, then it becomes meaningless. If any "dependency relationship" between two or more people is now a "marriage", then the only people who are not married to each other are hermits, and possibly, sworn enemies.

In particular, since the law allows same-sex adoption or fostering, same-sex "marriage" is already legal in every state of the union, and we can move on to other topics.

Friday, March 18, 2005

Ponzi's Scheme

The other day (Tuesday, actually, while I was out in the field), Dennis Prager was interviewing the author of Ponzi's Scheme.

The book focuses on the story of Charles Ponzi, the person after whom the notoriuous scheme is named.

It turns out, he's a very complex character. Those who know him only from the scheme that bears his name will find a fascinating story in and around the man's life.

Dennis explored several aspects of Ponzi's life from the perspective of a "moral bank account", an idea that's had a fair amount of influence on my thinking. If the scheme had been the only thing Ponzi had effected in his life, his name would deserve the stains it carries. However, he did other things as well, and even in the context of this scheme, there are mitigating factors.

...continued in full post...

Ponzi had come up with an idea for making money. It was basically a form of currency trading.

He realized that it was possible to buy international reply coupons (IRCs) in one country at one price, and sell them in another country at another price. Postage prices in different coutries hadn't caught up with actual costs in all cases. The problem was, he needed seed money.

Because of his past history, he had no credit, and no bank would loan him money. Especially since he wouldn't tell them what he intended to do with it, for fear they'd steal his idea.

He eventually went public, setting up an office and hanging out a shingle. His office, named, interestingly enough, the "Securities and Exchange Company", offered a 50% return on investment in three months' time.

People invested.

He was able to pay them back. However, since he kept running into trouble with the logistics trading IRCs, he paid his investors back with money from later investors. As long as he had more investors coming in, or letting their money ride, than collecting, he could keep his investors happy. All the time, as near as can be determined, he kept trying to get the logistics to work out.

Was this an intentional fraud? Probably not.

For one thing, about the time his company started raking in the dough, at the rate of $1 million per day, he started being treated for ulcers. For another, there was at least one occasion when he was walking around with an ocean cruise ticket in one pocket, and a draft in the other for enough money to buy that ocean liner outright.

He could have cut and run, and no one would have stopped him. He was recently married, and an overseas honeymoon would have not been suspicious.

All evidence shows he wanted to make this investment work.

Eventually, a determined newspaper editor started digging, and uncovered a past forged check, investors lost confidence, and the Securities and Exchange Company collapsed. Charles Ponzi served nearly a decade in prison, was deported to Italy, and eventually died in poverty.

Although his wife divorced him, she didn't re-marry until after he died, and kept up an amorous correspondence with him until he died.


Perhaps also due to Dennis Prager's influence, I put a lot of weight in those things people do that they don't have to. Before the Securites and Exchange Company, Ponzi worked a number of odd jobs, including a male nurse at a mining company. While he was at the mining company, a female nurse, with whom he was not involved in any way, was burned in a kerosene explosion. She needed skin grafts in order to live.

The camp's doctor was talking with him one evening, lamenting the fact that this poor woman was going to die, because no one was willing to donate skin, and Ponzi said, "take as much as you need."

"As much as you need" turned out to involve large patches from his back and thighs. He spent weeks in the hospital recovering, and would be scarred, and have to treat his scars to prevent infection, for the rest of his life.

The nurse was, needless to say, quite grateful, and the whole town voted Ponzi a heroism award, which he certainly deserved. Under the "moral bank account" model, one could argue that this one act is enough to offset the harm he caused with the Securities and Exchange Company. It certainly offset a good portion of it.

It was also completely optional. Everyone else in the camp had refused to donate skin. Ponzi could have declined, and it would have been – quite literally – no skin off his nose.

(Oh, come on. Don't tell me you expected me to resist that pun...

Tuesday, March 08, 2005

Corporate moral police

Dennis Prager has been discussing (and I believe intends to write his weekly article about) how Boeing has fired its president and CEO for adultery. The adultery took place on his own time. (Wizbang links to this article.

In a similar case, another company has adopted a policy of firing employees who smoke cigarettes on their own time.

I remember, years ago, Dr. Dean Edell would declare himself amazed at how we meekly surrender our urine and hair for drug testing, even though the drug use found was frequently away from work, on the employee's own time, and is detectable well after the effects have worn off.

The theory behind drug testing is that the cost of drug use is great enough to justify these invasions of privacy, and besides, if you don't want to be tested, you can work someplace else.

I don't advocate a law requiring or forbidding workplace testing. Indeed, I don't advocate laws requiring or forbidding any idiotic employment practice, as long as the employee has the option to leave. Instead, let consumers punish companies by taking their business elsewhere.

However, we see the effect of the slippery slope in action. When employers started demanding urine and hair samples to detect drug use, no one complained. (Well, some did, but not nearly enough.) Now, the precedent for testing for tobacco use is established. And if private adultery is a firing offense, does that justify hiring private detectives to follow employees around and take pictures?

What, if anything, is ruled out?

Friday, February 18, 2005

Success in Iraq? Don't want to know...

This article was mentioned on Dennis Prager's show yesterday.

But now our heroic and tragic liberal-intellectual capaciousness is facing its sharpest test since the collapse of the Soviet Union. Back then, most of us were forced, against our wills, to give Ronald Reagan a large share of credit for winning the Cold War. Now the people of this Bush-hating city are being forced to grant the merest possibility that Bush, despite his annoying manner and his administration’s awful hubris and dissembling and incompetence concerning Iraq, just might—might, possibly—have been correct to invade, to occupy, and to try to enable a democratically elected government in Iraq.

...continued in full post...

And now the terrible business of judging the correct price requires as much empirical rigor and moral clarity as we can muster, the sort of careful, “reality-based” judgments that liberals pride themselves on being able to make better than loony Evangelicals and cunning neocon dreamers. It won’t do simply to default to our easy predispositions—against Bush, even against war. If partisanship makes us abandon intellectual honesty, if we oppose what our opponents say or do simply because they are the ones saying or doing it, we become mere political short-sellers, hoping for bad news because it’s good for our ideological investment.

Tuesday, February 15, 2005

Dennis Prager vs. Talk Origins

Dennis Prager has been writing a series of articles making "The Case for Judeo-Christian Values" (currently up to part V). He became a target on the talk.origins newsgroup when he criticized evolution:

The second reason that the breakdown of Judeo-Christian values leads to a diminution of human worth is that if man was not created by God, the human being is mere stellar dust – and will come to be regarded as such. Moreover, people are merely the products of random chance, no more designed than a sand grain formed by water erosion. That is what the creationism-evolution battle is ultimately about – human worth. One does not have to agree with creationists or deny all evolutionary evidence to understand that the way evolution is taught, man is rendered a pointless product of random forces – unworthy of being saved before one's hamster.

Well, everyone has the right to be fuggheaded about one thing, and on his chosen topic, Dennis is exercising this right to the hilt. He claims to have no quarrel with evolution as the mechanism by which God made us, yet he writes passages like the above, and any crackpot with a book claiming evolution is all wrong can get a one-hour interview on his show, with no hint of "equal time" given to anyone from, say, the National Center for Science Education. He has said that few things upset him as much as when people lie, especially to themselves, I hope his blood-pressure medication is up to date.

In any event, the folks at talk.origins piled on with various criticisms. Unfortunately, most, if not all, have been invalid.

It's important, even when criticizing someone who is being deliberately wrong (which I don't believe to be the case with Mr. Prager), to keep the criticism on the constructive side, valid, and well out of the realm of personal attack. There are three reasons for this:

...continued in full post...

1: the target of the criticism may see flawed critiques for what they are, and decide the lack of substantive critiques means he's right.

2: he may not spot the flaw in a critique, and make changes to address the literal words of that critique, thereby doing something that doesn't address the problem.

3: in either case, any spectators (known in online fora as "lurkers" will also be evaluating any arguments offered in a discussion, and they will judge the merits of the case accordingly. Indeed, my usual practice is to avoid arguing evolution with a True Believer anywhere except a reasonably public forum. I know the True Believer is beyond convincing, but the spectators are frequently open-minded and truly open to whoever makes a good case.

So how did the talk.origins crowed do?

Dennis Prager asked:

Would you first save the dog you love or a stranger if both were drowning? The answer depends on your value system.

The first answer with any relevance, from "torch":

The absurd Judeo‑Christian world view has the exact opposite consequence. Someone holding Judeo‑Christian values should save the dog. Judeo‑Christian philosophy views the human life on earth as an infinitely short (by comparison) precursor to an infinitely long existence in heaven. In this absurd world view, the dogs single finite existence is worth infinitely more than humans continued existence in what this irrational philosophy believes is merely a vanishingly short temporary stage before true life begins in heaven. The Judeo‑Christian (or any eternal life religious) world view actually devalues human life ‑ but then its record over the past two thousand years states this case far more eloquently than I could

There are a number of objections to this position. For one thing, nonhuman life is widely regarded as not being able to appreciate its own mortality, and is thus not able to appreciate the gift of a long lifespan. The drowning dog is suffering because of immediate discomfort and/or pain, but is not able to think, "I'll never get to see the pups graduate from obedience school." Indeed, this is one interpretation of the curse of mortality being the result of eating the fruit of the Tree of Knowledge. On the day we ate of it, we became aware of our mortality. In short, the human is considered capable of appreciating that his life has been spared, the animal isn't. (And we may be in for some surprises some day.)

Secondly, if we are here as the result of a divine plan, then we are here for a reason, and it might not be a good idea to short-circuit that plan by checking out early, or causing others to do so.

I'm sure many Christian and Jewish scholars will be able to tell why this "objection" is ill-considered.

The "record over the past two thousand years" is worth considering, but it might be a good idea to look at the real record, especially in comparison with contemporaneous records. Although Christianity might not measure up as well as Christians would believe, I suspect it will fare much better than "torch" seems to think.


Next, "Augray" wrote:

Apparently, the only reason the writer can imagine for saving a stranger is because God tells you to.

Well, when he's not constrained by a word-count, he has mentioned that it's not the only reason, but it's certainly one of the most compelling, particularly in cases when a decision has to be made at once.

In a debate with a very well-educated atheist, Dennis asked what compelling reason the atheist had to violate any law, including laws against murder, if he was sure he wouldn't be caught. The atheist stated there was no compelling reason at all.

From the standpoint of cultural evolution, I believe those cultures that developed taboos against rape, murder, and many other crimes, proved to be fitter than cultures that didn't. As a result, those cultures are still around, and the ones that didn't have those taboos died out. However, part of what made these taboos effective was the notion, true or false, that "God would get you" if you violated them.

I may yet ask Augray if, were he drowning, would he rather a passer-by believe a lie about God watching and judging, or believe the truth that God didn't care, and spend the next half-hour weighing the pros and cons? (No, I don't believe those are the only choices that exist in the world. Those are merely the choices I'm offering Augray in this scenario.)


From rich hammett and others, we have responses like:

He's right, you know. I'm one of those eevil secular humanists, and I would save the dog I love (or the hamster, even) instead of Adolf Hitler, for instance.

Aside from being an instance of Godwin's Law, this is also an example of the fallacy of accident. As stated, the question refers to a typical human vs. a typical dog. If I saw Hitler drowning, the only thing I'd throw to him would be Saddam Hussein, in the hope each would drag the other down. But the question is not asking about Hitler, or about Lassie.


David Vestal adds:

That's one I haven't seen before--the Argument from You Are Special. Formulated: 1) You are very special, much more so than animals. 2) Who could deny that? 3) Therefore, God exists.

Actually, that's known as Wishful Thinking. It's a combination of an appeal to emotion and an appeal to consequences.

The argument runs: We believe we are special, we want to be special, and the existence of God makes us special, therefore God exists.

It should go without saying that whether or not God exists, and whether or not God had us in mind when he created the universe has no bearing on whether belief in God causes people to create a fitter society.


Another variation on the fallacy of accident is contributed by Tracy Hamilton:

Apparently, the only reason the writer can imagine for saving a stranger is because God tells you to.
Unless of course He tells you NOT to. Sorry, no room on the Ark for you, fella!

And of course here Noah was under specific orders. A particular time, not intended to be extended across all times and places, in contrast to "do not murder" and "do not stand by the blood of your neighbor".


I think I will eventually place more of this thread, with comments, on my web site.

Friday, February 11, 2005

Bad theories kill people

I was listening to Dennis Prager's first hour yesterday, and he spent some time discussing the various false beliefs certain groups hold. Among things he cited, a speaker who called the LAPD "the biggest gang in LA City", others who say blacks "fear the police as much as they fear gangs", and an article in The Guardian on Feb. 5 with some disturbing statistics regarding beliefs about AIDS.

According to a study carried out in the United States, 15% of black Americans believe that Aids is being used by the government as a form of genocide against black people. Almost half of them are convinced that the HIV virus is man-made, more than one quarter that it has been produced in a government laboratory, and 12% that it has been created and spread by the CIA.

Other theories about AIDS include the belief that the HIV virus is not the cause (Robert Mugabe famously believes this one); that the government is withholding a cure from the poor, and that the drugs used to treat HIV are actually part of a plot to use Blacks as guinea pigs.

The African-Americans who like to think that Aids is a government conspiracy against them have reason to hope this is the case. They must long for a comforting explanation, other than poverty, as to why it is that the disease affects them so disproportionately. They represent 13% of the American population, yet account for 50% of new HIV infections.

That's all well and good, but what is the result of believing a bad theory?

Remember, a theory is not a guess, or an unproven fact. A theory is a structure which purports to organize and account for observed facts. A good theory will account for lots of facts in one neat structure, and will accurately predict other facts. A bad theory will predict things that are not factual. The alternative to a good theory which predicts true things is not a blank slate, it's a bad theory, which predicts falsehoods.

What's more, what theories you believe affect how you will behave and what choices you will make.

If you believe that the police are as dangerous to you as the local gangs are, you will not call the police in to deal with gangs or other criminals. You will either sit there and let yourself be victimized by gangs, in the belief that at least that way, you're only being set upon by one group of thugs, or you will take matters into your own hands and try to deal with the situation yourself. This puts your own safety at risk, and you may endanger some innocent third party.

If you believe that AIDS is spread by the CIA, or that the government has a secret cure, or that it's not caused by HIV at all, you will not change those behaviors that put you at risk for contracting the virus.

If you believe poverty is due to a racist society and not due to how much you work, you will be poor all your life.

Lots of people believe, or disbelieve, particular theories because it makes them feel better. This leads them to act as if certain things are true, which are, in fact, false. At best, this will do them no good; at worst, it can kill them.

Monday, January 31, 2005

Same sex marriage

(A very old post.)
I had remarked on a Dennis Prager interview with two sociologists, John Borneman and Laurie Hart, on the subject of marriage. One of the things that had struck me during the interview was the wide variety of human relationships that could qualify as "marriage" under the definition being proposed.
I had taken a recording of the interview with me on a trip, and when I heard it again, I remembered that I had wanted to e-mail the interviewees and ask if this was an outrageous interpretation. Finding e-dresses was easy, and today, I received a reply.
On Sunday, May 30, 2004, at 01:09 AM, Karl Lembke wrote:
Greetings: I heard your interview with Dennis Prager on the subject of marriage. As the discussion went back and forth over the essential criteria that define "marriage", I was struck by the number of possible human institutions that could conceivably fit the definition. Given that the definition appears to encompass, in its indispensable points, little more than one person leaving a dependency relationship with one group and entering one with a different group, I'm wondering if it's possible to exclude legal adoption or fostering of a child from the definition of "marriage". In other words, does it violate the sense of the anthropological definition of "marriage" to regard an adopted child as having been "married" by its adoptive parents? Thank you for sitting for the interview.
Dear Karl, one of the more intelligent comments we received. In fact, you are right if one is consistent theoretically. That is, take the issue of care and dependency, as the basis for marriage. Of course, this is also an ideal condition, and necessary, but never sufficient in any particular place. Things are always tacked on (like age or class or residence restrictions, not to speak of sexual ones). Personally, given the delegitimation of class or race-based forms of exclusion, I favor a minimalist definition of marriage as those dependency relationships that require particular kinds of social care. all the best, John
Calling my comments "intelligent" is a good way to stay off of my bad side, and the rest of the reply sort of confirmed a though I had while listening to the interview. If we take the proposed definition of a transfer of dependency relationship from one group to another as a Generalized Anthropological Definition of Marriage (GAD), then "marriage" becomes defined so broadly as to be almost meaningless. At the very least...
... it would appear that legal adoption and fostering do fall under the Generalized Anthropologists' Definition (GAD) of "marriage". Therefore, same-sex marriage is already legal in this country, and we can quit fighting over the issue.
Like that'll ever work.

Thursday, January 27, 2005

Same sex marriage

This is a comment from a friend of mine, in response to Dennis Prager's article, What does 'Judeo-Christian' mean?

She started out by declaring herself appalled at his claim that Europeans believe in equality rather than liberty, "and the inference that the British, Germans, French, Spanish, Italians, and Netherlanders can be lumped in with the Hungarians, Poles, Rumanians, Albanians, Yugoslavians, and Russians." She wound up with the following:

If it is that important for children to be raised by both a man and a woman, then it would be logical for the government ot punish widows and widowers who had children but didn't remarry (perhaps by taking their children away to be raised by a pair of foster parents, perhaps merely by denying them deductions for their children on their income tax), just as it would be logical to punish divorced or single parents who didn't (re)marry and even married parents who didn't live together, or who had their children raised by nannies, au pairs, or boarding schools. In fact, it would logically follow that boarding schools should be required to have male and female couples as quasi-parents for children. I've read of some European Jewish communities that had the custom of requiring people who'd been married a certain amount of time (twenty years?) but had no children to get divorced and try again, and this would seem logical if the chief reason for marriage is to have children who are raised by a man and a woman. Has Prager denounced non-homosexual but single-sex parenting shows like "Family Affair" (with Mr. French) and "My Three Sons" as setting a bad example? (I don't watch sitcoms much any more, but I'm sure there are current ones that would also qualify for such denunciations.)

Quite a laundry list of comments on same-sex marriage. I've reproduced it in full here, typing it in from paper. Now, on to the fisk...


If it is that important for children to be raised by both a man and a woman, then it would be logical for the government to punish widows and widowers who had children but didn't remarry...

Hmmm... I think we need to be precise here. Many people argue that if marriage is about children, then any married couple that remains childless should have their marriage revoked, and infertile people should not be allowed to marry.

I'd say the point of marriage is to create the basic structure for a child-rearing unit – the "container" for children, if you will. Our society has decided the family structure it sanctions is a mother, a father, and an arbitrary number of children. By allowing only one person of each sex in any marriage, this guarantees the "container" into which children will be introduced meets that standard. You don't throw out a cup because it's empty at the moment.

Widows and widowers rarely become widows or widowers by choice. To punish them for an event beyond their control would do serious violence to our sense of fair play. Furthermore, the effect of a parent who dies is not the same as that of a parent who leaves the marriage. A dead parent will "live on" as a role model in the memory of the survivors. It's not the same as having the original parent around, but few things are.

Indeed, studies show that step parents are, among other things, more likely to abuse their step children, so forcing widowed parents to re-marry may be the cure-worse-than-the-disease. All social policies involve trade-offs, and this is one of them.


...it would be logical to punish divorced or single parents who didn't (re)marry and even married parents who didn't live together, or who had their children raised by nannies, au pairs, or boarding schools. In fact, it would logically follow that boarding schools should be required to have male and female couples as quasi-parents for children.

A lot of what I wrote about widows and widowers applies above.

One observation I have about divorce is that it's more important that both parents stay involved in the child's life than that they live under the same roof. It's one thing to divorce a spouse, but the expectation should be that you don't divorce the children. Indeed, a lot of changes in this area would be very useful. Among others, the default custody option should be a 50/50 split. And since the court retains jurisdiction, a parent who wants to relocate to a distant area should have to convince the judge that either it's necessary, or the relocating parent can continue to parent from that distance.

Nannies and au pairs should be able to meet high standards of ethics and professionalism. Many do. Some don't.

One of the drawbacks with nannies is that children are liable to bond to them. When they eventually leave, that's virtually the same as a divorce.

As for boarding schools, if the child is going to be spending significant amounts of time in one, there probably should be a set of "house parents". Legally, the school is in loco parentis to the child, but a whole school can't make the decisions about a child's care. Maybe boarding schools should be required, or at least strongly encouraged, to have "virtual parents" on staff. It's not one of the things we've thought about very hard. In the past, children's needs haven't been considered that important. (And nowadays, there seems to be an egalitarian trend which minimizes any differences between children and adults.)


Has Prager denounced non-homosexual but single-sex parenting shows like "Family Affair" (with Mr. French) and "My Three Sons" as setting a bad example? (I don't watch sitcoms much any more, but I'm sure there are current ones that would also qualify for such denunciations.)

This strikes me as a red herring. Now, I don't know the reason why the opposite sex parent isn't around, but given the time period I'm willing to bet large sums of money that the family started out with a mother and a father, and one of the parents died.

Dennis Prager has criticized shows where people set out to build a family without both a mother and a father from the start. "Murphy Brown", for example, where a single woman was planning to raise a child as a single mother. (The handyman may or may not have been a surrogate father.) I know he doesn't watch TV, so he may not be up on the latest sitcoms. If, however, anyone considers his point invalid because he hasn't denounced the latest sitcom that sets a bad example, do we get to consider that person's point invalid because he hasn't spoken up to defend the latest sitcom?


Ultimately, I'll pose the question Dennis poses when the debate over same-sex parenting, adoption by single parents or parents of one sex, or other alternatives to a mother and a father as parents.

Do you believe men and women bring different attributes to the table, or do you believe that men and women are (except for plumbing) interchangeable? If you believe there are no differences in what a father brings to the family and what a mother brings, it doesn't matter what sex the parents are, as long as there's the right number. If you believe the sexes are different, then it's very difficult, at best, for one to substitute for the other.